Home » Cabinets » Brighton Cabinets vs KraftMaid – A Surprising Comparison
Brighton Cabinets vs KraftMaid - A Surprising Comparison

Brighton Cabinets vs KraftMaid – A Surprising Comparison

by Jessica Miller

Navigating the world of kitchen and bathroom cabinetry can be overwhelming. Brighton Cabinets vs KraftMaid are two brands that often come up in the conversation, offering an array of options to fit various needs and budgets.

Picking the right cabinet can dramatically influence the look and functionality of your home.

Are you torn between Brighton’s renowned customization and KraftMaid’s durable finishes?

This article aims to provide a detailed comparison between the two, helping you make a well-informed decision.

Company Profiles

Understanding the background and unique offerings of Brighton Cabinets vs KraftMaid can be a cornerstone in making an educated purchasing decision.

Let’s delve into the histories, market positions, and special features of these two prominent brands.

History and Market Position of Brighton Cabinets

Brighton Cabinetry has carved a niche for itself by focusing on the middle market and offering cabinets of very good quality.

The brand is not a newcomer; it has built a reputation for providing custom cabinets at competitive prices. This places Brighton as an affordable yet reliable choice for those looking to invest in custom cabinetry.

Note: Brighton Cabinetry is particularly favored for its balance between quality and affordability.

Quality and Customization Options in Brighton

The brand excels in offering a high level of customization. From custom bathroom vanities to bookcases and kitchen cabinets, Brighton allows you to tweak features to your taste. In terms of construction, they utilize 1 1/2″ wide stiles and rails and 3/4″ solid hardwoods, standard plywood, and UV-treated birch veneer.

  • Customizable features include:
    1. Custom bathroom vanities
    2. Custom bookcases
    3. Custom cabinet doors
    4. Custom kitchen cabinets

KraftMaid’s Reputation and DuraKraft Plus Finish

KraftMaid is another brand that has garnered a strong following, particularly for its high-quality cabinets. One of the standout features is the DuraKraft Plus finish, which gives the cabinets an extra layer of protection, thereby enhancing their durability.

  • Core Features of KraftMaid:
    1. DuraKraft Plus finish
    2. 3/4’’ solid wood drawers
    3. Whisper Touch hinges
    4. Fully adjustable shelves

Note: KraftMaid cabinets are manufactured by the Masco Corporation, a large American manufacturer known for producing a wide array of home improvement and building products.

This section provides valuable insights into what each brand brings to the table, allowing you to weigh your options carefully.

Read Also: Kabinart vs KraftMaid – The Only Comparison You’ll Ever Need

Material and Construction

Selecting the right cabinet involves more than just aesthetics; the material and construction also play a pivotal role. This section aims to examine the wood choices and construction features that Brighton or KraftMaid Cabinets offer.

Wood Choices in Brighton Cabinets

Brighton Cabinets offers a variety of hardwood and softwood choices, providing you with the flexibility to match your aesthetic and functional needs. Among hardwoods, you can opt for maple, hickory, alder, or oak. In softwoods, cherry and birch are available.

  • Hardwoods:
    1. Maple
    2. Hickory
    3. Alder
    4. Oak
  • Softwoods:
    1. Cherry
    2. Birch

Wood Choices in KraftMaid Cabinets

KraftMaid provides an equally impressive range of wood choices, including Alder, Maple, Oak, Birch, Hickory, and Cherry. This broad spectrum ensures that whatever your preference or need, KraftMaid has got you covered.

  • Available Woods:
    1. Alder
    2. Maple
    3. Oak
    4. Birch
    5. Hickory
    6. Cherry

Note: It’s worth mentioning that both brands offer a robust array of wood choices, making them contenders in terms of material diversity.

Comparison of Cabinet Construction and Features

When it comes to construction and features, both brands offer solid choices. Brighton Cabinets uses 1 1/2″ wide stiles and rails, 3/4″ solid hardwoods, and standard plywood with UV-treated birch veneer. Drawers feature 1/4″ maple veneer panel captured bottoms and 5/8″ maple solid side front and back dovetailed construction.

KraftMaid, on the other hand, leverages its unique DuraKraft Plus finish for added durability. The drawers are constructed with 3/4” solid wood and have Whisper Touch hinges.

FeatureBrighton CabinetsKraftMaid Cabinets
Material for Stiles and Rails1 1/2″ wide stiles and rails3/4” face frames
Drawer Material5/8″ maple solid3/4″ solid wood
Special FinishesUV-treated birch veneerDuraKraft Plus
Drawer HingesStandardWhisper Touch
Customization of DimensionsUp to 1/16”Fully adjustable shelves

This detailed comparison allows you to assess which brand aligns closely with your specific needs in terms of material and construction.

Key Differences

Distinguishing between Brighton and KraftMaid Cabinets requires examining specific attributes. This section focuses on the key differences in door styles, finishes, and pricing between the two brands.

Door Style Variations

Brighton Cabinets prides itself on offering over 60 door styles, ranging from the classic Shaker to the more intricate Mullion. KraftMaid is not far behind, with over 50 door styles including everything from the timeless Raised Panel to modern Slab designs.

  • Brighton Door Styles:
    1. Shaker
    2. Mullion
    3. Beaded Inset
  • KraftMaid Door Styles:
    1. Raised Panel
    2. Slab
    3. Recessed Panel

Range of Finishes

When it comes to finishes, Brighton offers a range of options including painted, stained, and even exotic veneers. KraftMaid counters with its unique DuraKraft Plus Finishing system that provides exceptional durability and color retention.

  • Brighton Finishes:
    1. Painted
    2. Stained
    3. Exotic Veneers
  • KraftMaid Finishes:
    1. DuraKraft Plus
    2. Painted
    3. Stained

Note: The finishing options in both brands are commendable, but KraftMaid’s DuraKraft Plus offers a unique edge in durability.

Price Range Comparison

Pricing is inevitably a key consideration. Brighton Cabinets fall in the mid to high-end range, starting from $5,000 for a basic kitchen setup. KraftMaid is slightly more affordable, with starting prices around $4,000 for a similar configuration.

CriteriaBrighton CabinetsKraftMaid Cabinets
Starting Price$5,000$4,000
Mid-Range Price$8,000$7,000
High-End Price$12,000$10,000

This comparison aims to guide you in evaluating which brand better suits your budget and stylistic preferences.

Which is Better?

This crucial section aims to resolve the overarching question: Which cabinet brand offers the superior choice between Brighton and KraftMaid? Let’s delve into quality versus price, customization opportunities, and the overall value proposition.

Quality vs Price Analysis

Quality and price are usually at opposite ends of the spectrum. Brighton cabinets are renowned for their exceptional quality, particularly their use of high-end materials like cherry and oak. However, this comes at a premium, with prices generally starting at $5,000. KraftMaid, while slightly less luxurious in material selection, offers a durable and aesthetically pleasing product at a lower starting price of $4,000.

CriteriaBrighton CabinetsKraftMaid Cabinets
QualityHighModerate-High
Price$5,000+$4,000+

Customization Opportunities

Brighton takes the lead in customization options, offering a plethora of door styles, finishes, and even exotic veneers. KraftMaid also provides various customization options, but they primarily focus on functional elements like adjustable shelving and drawer dividers.

  • Brighton Customizations:
    1. Door Styles
    2. Finishes
    3. Exotic Veneers
  • KraftMaid Customizations:
    1. Door Styles
    2. Finishes
    3. Adjustable Shelving

Note: If individuality and unique design are high on your list, Brighton is the preferable choice.

Overall Value Proposition

Weighing all the factors, it becomes evident that Brighton is the go-to for those seeking a high-quality, highly customizable product and are willing to pay a premium for it. KraftMaid offers an excellent middle-ground option—good quality at a more affordable price point, albeit with fewer customization options.

To sum up, your choice between Brighton and KraftMaid will likely hinge on what you value more: premium quality and customization, or a balance between good quality and cost.

Read Also: Koch Cabinets vs KraftMaid – A Perfect Comparison

Conclusion

We’ve journeyed through the intricate worlds of Brighton Cabinets vs KraftMaid, examining their histories, material quality, customization options, and overall value. Brighton excels in quality and customization but comes at a premium price. KraftMaid offers a balance of quality and affordability.

For the luxury seeker willing to invest, Brighton is the optimal choice. However, if you aim for good quality without breaking the bank, KraftMaid proves to be a worthy alternative. In sum, each brand offers something valuable, fulfilling different needs for different lifestyles.