Home » Door and Windows » Great Lakes Windows vs Pella Comparison – Discover the Best
Great Lakes Windows vs Pella Comparison - Discover the Best

Great Lakes Windows vs Pella Comparison – Discover the Best

by Steven Wilson

When considering window solutions for your home, the debate of Great Lakes Windows vs Pella often surfaces. Each brand carries its unique identity and offerings, making the choice more than a mere purchase.

Understanding the nuances of Great Lakes Windows, established in 1981 and now a part of Ply Gem, versus Pella, a brand with a rich legacy since 1925, is crucial.

This comparison delves into their histories, showcasing how their long-standing presence in the market shapes their products and customer trust.

By dissecting their differences, from materials to customer satisfaction, we aim to guide homeowners to a decision that best fits their needs and enhances their living spaces.

Differences Between Great Lakes Windows and Pella

CriteriaGreat Lakes WindowsPella Windows
Company HistoryEstablished in 1981, owned by Ply Gem.Founded in 1925, longer history and stronger reputation.
Build MaterialPrimarily aluminum and vinyl.Wood, fiberglass, and vinyl.
Product VariationOffers a wider range of styles.Less variety, categorized by material rather than style.
DurabilityAluminum options are highly durable, suited for commercial use.Wood and fiberglass offer superior durability over vinyl.
Customer ReviewsPositive, with some complaints about vinyl quality and broken seals.Generally positive, fewer product complaints, service issues noted.
CostGenerally less expensive.More expensive.
ServiceRated better in service.Good service, but some issues with warranty fulfillment.

Key Comparison: Great Lakes Windows and Pella

In the window industry, understanding the differences between Great Lakes Windows vs Pella is crucial for homeowners seeking quality, style, and value.

Build Material and Quality

  • Comparison of Materials Used by Both Brands

Great Lakes Windows primarily utilizes aluminum and vinyl, offering robustness and durability, especially in their aluminum range. Pella, on the other hand, diversifies its materials to include wood, fiberglass, and vinyl, catering to varied aesthetic and functional needs.

  • Assessing the Durability of Great Lakes and Pella Windows

Durability is a hallmark of both brands. Great Lakes’ aluminum windows are especially suited for commercial applications, while Pella’s wood and fiberglass options are renowned for their longevity, outperforming vinyl in many aspects.

Read Also: ProVia Windows vs Andersen – The Ultimate Battle

  • Suitability for Different Climates and Environments

The choice of material affects a window’s performance in different environments. Great Lakes’ vinyl and aluminum windows are known for their resistance to weathering and maintenance ease, making them suitable for various climates. Pella’s wood windows, while offering an upscale look, require more maintenance but excel in insulation, ideal for colder regions.

Style and Product Variety

  • Range of Styles Offered by Great Lakes Windows

Great Lakes stands out with a broader array of style options, allowing homeowners to find windows that precisely match their home’s architectural design and personal taste.

  • Pella’s Approach to Window Styling

Pella categorizes its products more by material than style. This approach simplifies the selection process for customers who have a clear preference for wood, fiberglass, or vinyl.

  • Matching Windows to Home Architecture

The style of windows chosen can significantly enhance a home’s architectural beauty. While Great Lakes offers versatility in design, Pella’s distinct material-focused categories offer a different kind of aesthetic flexibility.

Customer Reviews and Brand Reputation

  • Analyzing Customer Feedback and Satisfaction

Both brands enjoy positive customer feedback overall. However, nuances in customer experiences are notable, with some reports of issues concerning product quality and service.

  • Common Complaints and Praises for Each Brand

Great Lakes Windows occasionally faces criticism regarding the quality of their vinyl windows and issues like broken seals. Pella, while receiving fewer product complaints, sometimes encounters service and warranty fulfillment challenges.

  • Brand Reputation in the Window Industry

Despite these concerns, both brands have established a commendable reputation in the window industry, with their long histories and commitment to quality playing a significant role in building customer trust.

Cost and Value for Money

  • Price Comparison Between Great Lakes and Pella

When it comes to cost, Great Lakes Windows generally positions itself as the more budget-friendly option compared to Pella.

  • Understanding the Value Proposition of Each Brand

While Pella might be more expensive, it’s crucial to consider the value offered in terms of durability, material quality, and aesthetic appeal. Great Lakes offers economic options without significantly compromising quality.

  • Long-term Cost Benefits of Quality Windows

Investing in quality windows can yield long-term benefits in energy efficiency, maintenance costs, and enhancing property value. Both Great Lakes and Pella offer products that can contribute to these long-term savings, albeit in different ways.

Which is Better? Making an Informed Choice

Choosing between Great Lakes Windows and Pella requires careful consideration of individual needs, long-term benefits, and overall satisfaction.

Assessing Needs and Preferences

  • Identifying Personal Requirements for Windows

Each homeowner has unique needs based on their home’s architecture, climate, and personal style preferences. While Great Lakes offers a wide range of styles, Pella’s material-focused approach might better suit those with specific aesthetic or material preferences.

  • Matching Window Features with Homeowner Needs

Consider factors like:

  • Climate: Durability against local weather conditions.
  • Aesthetics: Style that complements your home.
  • Maintenance: Ease of upkeep over the years.

Analyzing Long-term Benefits

  • Evaluating Durability and Maintenance Needs

Durability isn’t just about longevity; it’s also about maintaining performance and appearance over time. Great Lakes’ aluminum options offer robustness, while Pella’s wood and fiberglass are known for their endurance.

  • Considering Energy Efficiency and Cost Savings

Efficient windows can significantly reduce energy bills. It’s essential to weigh the initial investment against potential savings. Both brands offer energy-efficient options, but the choice depends on your specific energy needs and budget.

Making the Final Decision

  • Weighing Pros and Cons


  • Material quality: Does it meet your longevity expectations?
  • Style range: Does it offer the variety you need?
  • Customer feedback: Are there recurring issues you should be aware of?
  • Understanding the Impact of Warranty and Service

A warranty can offer peace of mind, while good service ensures any issues are promptly addressed. Great Lakes is known for better service, whereas Pella, despite offering good service, sometimes faces challenges with warranty fulfillment.

The decision between Great Lakes Windows and Pella goes beyond just product comparison; it’s about finding the right fit that aligns with your individual requirements, offers long-term value, and ensures satisfaction for years to come.

Read Also: Kolbe Windows vs Pella – Who Comes Out on Top?


In wrapping up our comparison between Great Lakes Windows vs Pella, we see clear distinctions in materials, styles, durability, and customer satisfaction.

This decision is not just about aesthetics or budget; it’s about understanding your specific needs and how each brand aligns with them.

We encourage homeowners to delve deeper, consult professionals, and thoroughly research to ensure the choice made enhances their living spaces.

Ultimately, whether it’s the diverse styles of Great Lakes or the material-centric approach of Pella, the right decision hinges on informed, thoughtful consideration.