The subject of KraftMaid vs Merillat Cabinets has drawn much attention as people realize the vital role that cabinets play in shaping the aesthetics and functionality of a home.
While cabinets may appear as simple storage solutions, the brand you opt for can have far-reaching implications. KraftMaid and Merillat are both esteemed names in the cabinet industry, each offering a unique set of benefits and challenges.
This article aims to provide a thorough comparison between the two brands, helping you make an informed decision for your home improvement project.
Quick Comparison
| Criteria | KraftMaid | Merillat |
|---|---|---|
| Company Background | Part of Masco Companies, also contributes to Brookhaven line for Woodmode | Part of Masco Companies |
| Finishing System | DuraKraft Plus system | Edge profile sanding technique |
| Grade Options | Custom, Semi-Custom, Stock | Masterpiece, Classic |
| Finish Options | Painted, Color-match, Translucent, Stains, Weathered, Aged | Stained, Glazed, Thermofoil, Distressed, Painted, Vintage |
| Design and Build | 3/4-inch hanging rail, I-Beam construction | 3/8-inch particle board sides, plastic corner braces |
| Product Lines and Quality | Known for excellent quality, deep drawers, adjustable shelves | Known for good quality, quiet drawer operation, automatic closing hinges |
| Construction and Durability | Solid wood construction, scratch-resistant face frames | Hardened steel front frames |
| Material | Robust materials even in un-upgraded versions | 3/8″ particle board sides and plastic corner braces in classic line |
| Price | Higher priced due to upgrades and innovations | More cost-effective |
| Warranty Conditions | Lifetime limited warranty | Lifetime limited warranty and 25-year limited warranty |
| Brand Perception and Quality Issues | Mixed reviews, concerns about corporate changes affecting quality | Mixed reviews, concerns about corporate changes affecting quality |
| Customer Experiences | Varied; some issues with customer service but also praise for quality | Varied; some praise for durability but also quality concerns |
Key Features and Attributes
The crux of choosing between KraftMaid and Merillat lies in understanding their respective features and attributes.
Here, we compare and contrast these brands based on company backgrounds, grades of cabinets offered, finishing systems, and material and build quality.
Comparing Company Backgrounds
Both KraftMaid and Merillat operate under the umbrella of the Masco Companies. However, they have distinct histories and market focuses.
- Shared Parent Company: “Masco Companies”
- KraftMaid: Founded in 1969, primarily targets the premium market segment.
- Merillat: Established in 1946, caters to a broader market, including entry-level consumers.
- Notable Contributions to Other Lines
- KraftMaid has been instrumental in pioneering premium cabinets with innovative design.
- Merillat has diversified its portfolio, offering other lines like countertops and interior fittings.
Note: Understanding the company background may help consumers align their choices with the brand’s market focus and product lines.
Exploring the Different Grades
Both brands offer a range of grades, tailored to fit different needs and budgets.
- KraftMaid’s Custom
- Features include soft-close doors, full-overlay design, and nearly unlimited customization options.
- Semi-Custom, Stock Options
- KraftMaid also provides semi-custom and stock options, albeit with limited features.
- Merillat’s Masterpiece and Classic Grades
- Masterpiece caters to higher-end consumers with features like dovetail drawer construction.
- Classic is the budget-friendly line with fewer customization options.
A Close Look at Finishing Systems
The finish on your cabinets plays a significant role in both aesthetics and durability.
- Merillat’s Aging Technique
- Incorporates an aging process that imparts a unique, rustic look.
- KraftMaid’s DuraKraft Plus System
- Uses a multi-step process that includes both staining and sealing, resulting in a durable finish.
Note: The choice of finish can greatly influence the cabinet’s longevity and aesthetic appeal.
Material and Build Quality
Both brands vary considerably in terms of materials used and build quality.
- KraftMaid’s Robust Construction
- Primarily uses solid wood and plywood, making for a sturdy, long-lasting product.
- Merillat’s Use of Particle Board and Plastic Braces
- Makes use of less expensive materials like particle board and plastic braces, especially in their Classic line.
| Brand | Material | Notable Features |
|---|---|---|
| KraftMaid | Solid wood | DuraKraft Plus finish |
| Merillat | Particle board | Budget-friendly Classic line |
This examination of key features and attributes equips you with the necessary insights to make a well-informed choice between KraftMaid and Merillat.
Key Differences and How to Choose
Determining the best cabinet brand for your needs involves analyzing several factors such as price, durability, design options, and customer experiences.
This section will guide you through these critical aspects, comparing KraftMaid and Merillat along the way.
Price Points and What They Mean
Price often becomes a defining factor in choosing between KraftMaid and Merillat.
- Is Merillat More Cost-Effective?
- Generally, Merillat cabinets are less expensive, primarily due to the use of more affordable materials like particle board.
- Are KraftMaid’s Upgrades Worth the Cost?
- KraftMaid’s higher price point is reflective of its more premium offerings, such as custom-built units and a vast array of finishes.
| Brand | Price Range | Notable Inclusions |
|---|---|---|
| KraftMaid | High-end | Customization, solid wood |
| Merillat | Mid to low range | Particle board, plastic |
Note: A higher price does not always equate to higher value. It depends on what features you prioritize.
Durability and Long-Term Value
A cabinet’s life expectancy is crucial when weighing KraftMaid against Merillat.
- Insights into KraftMaid’s Durable Construction
- The use of solid wood and robust finishes assures longevity, even if the initial cost is high.
- Merillat’s Reputation for Durability
- Merillat offers reliable durability, especially in their Masterpiece line, albeit at a lower price point.
Note: Durability should be considered alongside price to determine long-term value.
Finish and Design Options
Both brands offer a variety of finishes and designs, but they cater to different tastes and needs.
- Comparing the Aesthetic Flexibility of Both Brands
- KraftMaid provides a broader range of finish and design options, suitable for various interior design themes.
- The Importance of Exterior Finish in Your Choice
- Merillat’s finishes, particularly the aging techniques, might appeal to those seeking a more traditional or rustic aesthetic.
Note: Your choice of finish and design will have a lasting impact on your home’s overall look and feel.
Customer Experiences and Brand Perception
Customer feedback plays an influential role in choosing between these two brands.
- Quality Concerns for Both Brands
- Both brands have had complaints, but they differ in nature. KraftMaid concerns often relate to the high cost, while Merillat’s usually focus on material quality.
- How Customer Feedback Could Influence Your Decision
- Positive reviews for KraftMaid often highlight the brand’s longevity and superior build, whereas Merillat reviews commend its cost-effectiveness and functional design.
| Brand | Common Positive Feedback | Common Concerns |
|---|---|---|
| KraftMaid | Longevity, superior build | High cost |
| Merillat | Cost-effectiveness | Material quality |
Being cognizant of these key differences between KraftMaid vs Merillat Cabinets can aid you in making a choice that suits your specific needs and preferences.
Conclusion
We’ve reached the concluding part of our analysis comparing KraftMaid vs Merillat Cabinets, tying together the key differences and recommendations.
While KraftMaid excels in higher-end customizations and durable materials, Merillat is more budget-friendly, offering practical designs without compromising much on quality.
The final verdict is not universally applicable; the better choice depends on individual requirements and budget.
Armed with this comprehensive review, you are now better equipped to make a well-informed decision that aligns with your specific needs, be it the elegance and robustness of KraftMaid or the affordability and efficiency of Merillat.
