Home » Door and Windows » Ply Gem Windows vs Milgard – Which is the Right Choice?
Ply Gem Windows vs Milgard - Which is the Right Choice?

Ply Gem Windows vs Milgard – Which is the Right Choice?

by Steven Wilson

Choosing the right windows for your home is more than just a design decision; it’s about comfort, efficiency, and value. In the world of window brands, Ply Gem Windows vs Milgard stand out for their quality and innovation.

Ply Gem offers a wide range of window types, including the popular 2000 Double Hung Window and the 5100 Casement Awning Window, catering to various architectural styles and personal preferences.

On the other hand, Milgard is celebrated for its custom, energy-efficient designs, featuring materials like fiberglass and wood, appealing to those seeking a blend of elegance and functionality.

Both brands bring their unique strengths to the table, but how do they really compare?

This comparison aims to uncover which brand could be the right fit for your home, considering various factors such as product offerings, energy efficiency, pricing, and customer feedback.

Quick Comparison Table: Ply Gem Windows vs Milgard

FeaturePly Gem WindowsMilgard
Product OfferingsVarious windows including 2000 Double Hung, Single Hung 6100 Series, 5100 Casement Awning Window, Sliding WindowsAluminum, Vinyl, Fiberglass, Wood windows
MaterialsVinyl, composite, wood-clad, aluminum-clad MIRA seriesFiberglass, vinyl, wood, aluminum
Finish Colors2 to 11 exterior options, up to 5 interior choicesVaries by type; up to 16 colors for Fiberglass Essence Series
Energy EfficiencyEnergy-efficient, some vinyl windows rated ‘Most Efficient’ by Energy StarSlightly more energy-efficient with a focus on energy savings
Warranty CoverageVaries by model, lifetime warranty on many models, covers replacement and refinish including laborLifetime coverage for parts and installation, full lifetime warranty
Lead Time4 to 8 weeks4 to 10 weeks
Pricing$400 – $650 per window for full installationAround $227 for a single hung vinyl window from the Style Line series, plus installation
Customer Feedback & BBB Ratings“F” rating with BBB, issues with warranty, high Home Depot reviews, low BBB customer scoreWell-regarded for quality and performance, over 50 years in industry
InstallationProfessional and DIY installation possible, warranty considerations for DIYEasy installation, suitable for DIY or professional
Overall AssessmentKnown for durability, variety, customer service, and warranty issuesElegant designs, variety of styles, top quality and performance, strong focus on customer satisfaction and warranties

Overview of Ply Gem Windows

Ply Gem Windows stands as a notable player in the home improvement market, offering a diverse range of windows that cater to different architectural and design needs.

Let’s take a closer look at what sets Ply Gem apart in terms of variety, materials, innovation, and energy efficiency.

Variety and Features of Ply Gem Windows

Ply Gem’s product offerings are extensive and varied, ensuring that there’s something for every homeowner.

Their range includes:

  • 2000 Double Hung Window: A classic choice for traditional homes.
  • Double Hung Window (Premium and Pro Series – Vinyl): Offers enhanced features for modern homes.
  • Single Hung 6100 Series: Combines style and functionality.
  • 5100 Casement Awning Window: Ideal for contemporary designs.
  • Sliding Windows (Contractor, 6100, Premium, and Pro Series – Vinyl): Perfect for those seeking ease of use and simple elegance.

This array of options means that Ply Gem can cater to a wide variety of aesthetic and functional preferences, making them a versatile choice for many homeowners.

Read Also: Stanek Windows vs Pella? A Solid Comparison

Ply Gem’s Materials and Innovation

Ply Gem doesn’t just focus on variety; they also emphasize the quality of their materials and their commitment to innovation.

Their windows are made from:

  • Vinyl: Durable and low-maintenance, suitable for a range of climates.
  • Composite: A blend of materials that offers the best of both worlds in terms of durability and aesthetic appeal.
  • Wood-clad Frames: Providing the classic beauty of wood with enhanced durability.
  • Aluminum-clad MIRA Series: Combining the strength of aluminum with the style of traditional window designs.

These materials are chosen for their longevity, aesthetic appeal, and ability to withstand various environmental conditions, ensuring that Ply Gem windows are not just beautiful, but also built to last.

Energy Efficiency in Ply Gem’s Design

Energy efficiency is a key concern for homeowners today, and Ply Gem addresses this need head-on. Their windows are designed to be not only stylish but also energy-efficient.

Key features include:

  • Low-E Glass: Minimizes UV and infrared light, keeping homes cooler in summer and warmer in winter.
  • Energy Star Rated Models: Some of their vinyl windows have been recognized as ‘Most Efficient’ by Energy Star, offering upgraded glass packages that enhance energy savings.

By focusing on energy efficiency, Ply Gem ensures that homeowners can enjoy lower heating and cooling bills, while also contributing to a more sustainable environment.

In summary, Ply Gem offers a well-rounded selection of windows that combine style, durability, and energy efficiency, making them a strong contender in the window market.

Their commitment to quality materials and innovative design ensures that their products are not just an aesthetic addition to homes, but also a practical and environmentally friendly choice.

Overview of Milgard Windows

Milgard Windows, with over 50 years in the industry, is renowned for its commitment to quality, innovation, and customer satisfaction.

This section delves into the diversity, craftsmanship, and customizable efficiency that Milgard offers, setting it apart in the window market.

Diverse Range of Milgard Windows

Milgard’s range is notable for its variety and customizability, catering to different architectural styles and personal tastes.

Their offerings include:

  • Fiberglass Windows: Known for durability and design flexibility.
  • Vinyl Windows: Popular for their energy efficiency and minimal maintenance.
  • Wood Windows: Offer a classic and elegant appeal.
  • Aluminum Windows: Provide a sleek, modern look with robust performance.

Milgard’s six window lines, such as single-hung, double-hung, and specialty windows like bay/bow and garden windows, ensure that there’s a Milgard window for every kind of home.

Quality and Style in Milgard’s Craftsmanship

Quality is a hallmark of Milgard’s brand.

They are recognized for:

  • Custom Designs: Tailored to meet specific architectural needs.
  • Energy-Efficient Solutions: Windows designed to conserve energy and reduce heating and cooling costs.
  • Variety of Colors: Especially in the Fiberglass Essence Series, offering up to 16 color options.

Milgard’s focus on quality craftsmanship not only enhances the aesthetic appeal of homes but also ensures long-term durability and performance.

Customization and Efficiency with Milgard

Milgard stands out for its blend of customization and efficiency.

Key aspects include:

  • Customizable Options: Windows designed to fit unique sizes and styles.
  • Energy Efficiency: Focus on energy-saving features to reduce utility bills.
  • Color Choices: Wide range of colors, especially in the Fiberglass Essence Series.

With Milgard, homeowners have the flexibility to tailor their windows to their exact preferences while benefiting from energy-saving features.

This combination of customization and efficiency makes Milgard a go-to choice for those looking to enhance their homes both aesthetically and functionally.

Comparing Ply Gem and Milgard Windows Side by Side

When choosing between Ply Gem windows vs Milgard windows, understanding their differences is crucial.

This section offers a side-by-side comparison, focusing on style, energy efficiency, and warranty services, to help you make an informed decision.

Style and Variety Showdown

Both Ply Gem and Milgard offer a wide range of styles and designs, but their approaches differ:

  • Ply Gem: Offers a broad spectrum including the 2000 Double Hung Window and 5100 Casement Awning Window, catering to various architectural styles.
  • Milgard: Known for their custom designs, offering unique styles like bay/bow and garden windows, with a focus on aesthetic flexibility.

While Ply Gem provides a versatile selection for different home styles, Milgard excels in offering customizable options that can be tailored to specific architectural needs.

Energy Efficiency and Eco-Friendliness Face-Off

Energy efficiency is a key factor in choosing windows:

  • Ply Gem: Some of their vinyl windows are rated ‘Most Efficient’ by Energy Star, indicating superior energy performance.
  • Milgard: Slightly edges out with a focus on energy-efficient designs, aiming to reduce heating and cooling costs.

Both brands emphasize energy efficiency, but Milgard’s dedication to energy-saving designs might offer more long-term savings and environmental benefits.

Warranty and Support Services Compared

Warranty coverage is an important aspect of post-purchase satisfaction:

  • Ply Gem: Offers varying warranty coverage depending on the product, with a lifetime warranty on various models.
  • Milgard: Provides a more comprehensive lifetime coverage for both parts and installation, covering full costs in case of defects or installation faults.

Milgard’s all-encompassing warranty coverage provides an added layer of security and customer assurance, which can be a significant deciding factor for many homeowners.

In this comparison, while Ply Gem offers a wide variety of styles and some highly energy-efficient options, Milgard stands out with its customizability, superior energy efficiency, and comprehensive warranty coverage.

This side-by-side look aims to provide clearer insights into which brand might suit your specific needs and preferences better.

Which is Better? Analyzing Ply Gem Windows and Milgard

Deciding between Ply Gem windows vs Milgard windows isn’t just about choosing a product; it’s about finding the right balance of cost, quality, reputation, durability, and ease of installation.

This section dives into these aspects to help you determine which brand might be the better choice for your home.

Cost Versus Quality: Finding the Balance

When it comes to cost versus quality, both brands have their strengths:

  • Ply Gem: Known for offering affordable options. For example, their vinyl frames are budget-friendly, while their aluminum-clad MIRA series is on the higher end.
  • Milgard: Prices vary, but they are known for providing value for money. For instance, their single hung vinyl window from the Style Line series is priced around $227, not including installation and labor.

While Ply Gem offers a range of prices suitable for different budgets, Milgard’s pricing reflects its commitment to quality and energy efficiency.

Hearing from Customers: Reputation and Feedback

Customer feedback and company reputation are critical indicators of satisfaction:

  • Ply Gem: Despite high reviews on platforms like Home Depot, Ply Gem has a lower BBB rating (“F”) with complaints mainly about warranty issues.
  • Milgard: Generally well-regarded for their quality and performance, with a long-standing reputation in the industry.

Milgard’s focus on customer satisfaction and quality seems to resonate better with consumers, giving them an edge in terms of reputation.

What to Consider: Durability and Installation Ease

Durability and ease of installation are also crucial factors:

  • Ply Gem: Offers professional and DIY installation options, but DIY might affect warranty terms.
  • Milgard: Known for easy installation processes, whether DIY or professional, without compromising on warranty.

Milgard’s windows provide a balance of durability, aesthetic appeal, and user-friendly installation, making them a favorable option for those looking for long-term value.

In sum, while Ply Gem provides affordable and varied window options, Milgard edges ahead with its combination of quality, customer satisfaction, durability, and ease of installation.

Your choice will depend on your specific needs and priorities, whether it’s budget, style, energy efficiency, or long-term value.

Read Also: American Vision Windows vs Milgard – The Essential Comparison


In the Ply Gem Windows vs Milgard debate, it’s clear that both brands have their unique strengths.

Ply Gem offers affordability and a wide range of styles, making it a great option for budget-conscious homeowners who don’t want to compromise on style.

Milgard, on the other hand, shines with its commitment to quality, energy efficiency, and customer satisfaction, catering to those looking for long-term value.

Personalizing your window choice is key. Consider what matters most to you – is it the initial cost, the style, energy efficiency, or the warranty and service? Your priorities will guide your decision.

Finally, when confidently choosing windows, always consider the long-term impact of your choice on your home’s comfort, energy bills, and resale value. Both Ply Gem and Milgard offer compelling options, but the best choice will always align with your personal needs and the specific requirements of your home.