Home » Door and Windows » Simonton vs Milgard Windows Complete Comparison
Simonton vs Milgard Windows Complete Comparison

Simonton vs Milgard Windows Complete Comparison

by Steven Wilson

In the quest for home improvement, the choice of windows plays a crucial role. As we delve into the realms of Simonton vs Milgard Windows, two prominent brands emerge, each with a unique story to tell.

Simonton, established in 1946 and now part of Ply Gem, offers a diverse range of window styles across 12 series. Milgard, founded in 1958, stands out for its custom window solutions, available in various styles across five series.

The need to compare these brands becomes evident as homeowners seek to make informed decisions that blend style, quality, and value.

This comparison will not only highlight key differences and similarities but also guide you in selecting the right windows for your home, considering aspects like product offerings, quality, pricing, and energy efficiency.

Comparison Table Between Simonton and Milgard Windows

FeatureSimonton WindowsMilgard Windows
Company BackgroundEstablished in 1946, part of Ply Gem.Founded in 1958.
PopularityStrong market presence.Highly sought after.
Product OfferingsSpecializes in vinyl windows.Offers aluminum, vinyl, fiberglass, wood.
Product QualityLong-lasting, energy-efficient, affordableQuality dual pane windows.
Finish Colors8 exterior finishes, 6 interior wood stainsUp to 16 color options in Fiberglass.
Window StylesNine styles with various materials.Seven styles with various materials.
Lead Time3-6 weeks.4-10 weeks.
Pricing$200 – $1,300 per window.$170 – $1,890 per window.
WarrantyDouble-Lifetime Limited Warranty.Full Lifetime Warranty for specific series
Energy EfficiencyENERGY-STAR certified, Low-E glass.Dual/triple glazed, Low-E coatings.

Key Comparison: Simonton Windows and Milgard Windows

In the competitive world of window manufacturing, Simonton vs Milgard stand out as industry leaders.

This section delves into their heritage, product offerings, design choices, pricing, and warranty, providing a comprehensive comparison.

Company Heritage and Market Presence

  • Origin and evolution of Simonton Windows

Simonton’s journey began in 1946, evolving from a small family business into a significant part of Ply Gem. Its long-standing history reflects a deep-rooted commitment to quality and innovation in window manufacturing.

  • The founding and growth of Milgard Windows

Milgard’s story started in 1958. It has since carved a niche for itself in the window market, known for its custom window and door solutions. Milgard’s growth trajectory highlights its focus on customer-centric designs and quality craftsmanship.

  • Market positioning and popularity trends

While Simonton enjoys a solid market presence, indicated by its selection for sale by entities like Custom Exchange Inc, Milgard is frequently sought after, reflecting high consumer interest. The brands’ market positioning underscores their reputation and consumer preference in the window industry.

Read Also: Sierra Pacific Windows vs Marvin – In-Depth Comparison

Diverse Product Offerings and Quality

  • Range of products offered by Simonton

Simonton specializes in vinyl windows, boasting various collections such as Reflections, Asure, Impressions, and more. Its focus is on providing a wide range of styles to suit different architectural needs.

  • Variety and uniqueness in Milgard’s offerings

Milgard, on the other hand, offers a broader range of materials, including aluminum, vinyl, fiberglass, and wood. This diversity allows Milgard to cater to a more varied customer base with specific needs.

  • Comparison of product quality and innovation

Both brands offer quality products, but with different focuses. Simonton is praised for its energy-efficient and affordable options, well-suited for areas like the Bay Area.

Milgard’s dual pane windows are an upgrade from older single pane models, reflecting its commitment to modernizing window technology.

Style, Material, and Design Choices

  • Analyzing the window styles and materials of Simonton

Simonton provides nine window styles, majorly in vinyl, but also includes options like aluminum-clad wood and fiberglass. This variety ensures customers can find a perfect match for their homes.

  • Milgard’s approach to window styles and materials

Milgard offers seven window styles with a mix of materials such as vinyl, fiberglass, aluminum, and wood composite frames. Its approach is geared towards providing both functionality and aesthetic appeal.

  • Evaluating design flexibility and customization options

When it comes to customization, Milgard leads with its Fiberglass Essence Series offering 16 color options, while Simonton offers 8 exterior finishes and 6 interior wood stains, showing their commitment to meeting diverse customer preferences.

Pricing, Value, and Investment

  • Price range comparison for both brands

Simonton’s windows range from $200 to $1,300 per window, whereas Milgard’s vary from $170 to $1,890. This pricing reflects the brands’ different approaches to materials and customization options.

  • Assessing the value for money and ROI

While both brands offer competitive pricing, the value for money lies in their durability, energy efficiency, and aesthetic value. The investment in these windows goes beyond mere cost, considering long-term savings in energy bills and maintenance.

  • How pricing affects consumer choice

Pricing plays a significant role in consumer decision-making. Simonton’s affordable range makes it an attractive option for budget-conscious customers, while Milgard’s higher-end products appeal to those seeking more premium options.

Warranty and Customer Assurance

  • Warranty policies of Simonton Windows

Simonton offers a Double-Lifetime Limited Warranty, covering vinyl components, hardware, and screens. This warranty, transferable to subsequent owners, underscores the brand’s confidence in its products.

  • Milgard Windows approach to customer assurance

Milgard provides a Full Lifetime Warranty for specific series and a general Lifetime Limited Warranty. This variation in warranty policies caters to different customer needs and product lines.

  • Impact of warranty on brand trust and reliability

A robust warranty policy significantly influences consumer trust. Simonton’s double lifetime warranty and Milgard’s full lifetime warranty for select series reflect their commitment to quality and customer satisfaction, making them reliable choices in the window market.

Which is Better? Evaluating Simonton and Milgard for Your Needs

Choosing the right windows for your home involves weighing factors like energy efficiency, installation, aesthetics, and support.

Let’s compare Simonton vs Milgard Windows to see which might better suit your needs.

Assessing Energy Efficiency and Eco-Friendliness

  • Energy efficiency features in Simonton windows

Simonton windows are ENERGY-STAR certified, featuring Argon-gas-filled, Low-E glass, and double glazing. These features contribute to reduced heat transfer, consistent interior temperatures, and energy savings.

  • Milgard’s commitment to energy-saving designs

Milgard focuses on energy efficiency with dual/triple glazed glass, Argon gas insulation, and SunCoat® Low-E Glass Coatings. These innovations are designed for optimal thermal performance, enhancing energy conservation.

  • The environmental impact of window choices

Both brands show a commitment to eco-friendliness, but the choice between them depends on specific energy-saving features and your home’s requirements. Milgard’s extensive range of Low-E glass options may offer higher energy efficiency for certain needs.

Lead Times and Installation Considerations

  • Comparing the lead times of both brands
  • Simonton: 3-6 weeks.
  • Milgard: 4-10 weeks.

These time frames are crucial for project planning, especially in time-sensitive renovations or constructions.

  • Installation process and ease for Simonton and Milgard

Both brands provide professional installation services, but the ease and efficiency of installation can vary. Simonton’s shorter lead time may be advantageous for urgent projects.

  • Importance of timely installation in project planning

Delays in window installation can affect the overall timeline of home improvement projects. Hence, considering lead times and installation efficiency is vital in your decision-making process.

Color and Finish Options for Aesthetic Appeal

  • Exploring the color and finish range of Simonton

Simonton offers 8 exterior finishes and 6 interior wood stains, allowing for a fair degree of customization to match your home’s style.

  • Milgard’s approach to aesthetic diversity

Milgard stands out in this category with its Fiberglass Essence Series offering up to 16 color options, providing greater flexibility in achieving the desired aesthetic.

  • The role of aesthetics in window selection

Aesthetics play a significant role in window selection. While Simonton provides a decent range of options, Milgard’s extensive color palette caters to those seeking more specific or varied aesthetic requirements.

Customer Support and Post-Purchase Services

  • Analyzing customer support quality of both brands

Both Simonton vs Milgard Windows are known for their reliable customer support, but experiences can vary. It’s important to research and read customer reviews to gauge satisfaction levels.

  • Post-purchase services and their importance

The quality of post-purchase services, including warranty claims and support, contributes significantly to overall customer satisfaction. Both brands offer comprehensive warranties, but the ease of accessing these services can differ.

  • Consumer feedback and satisfaction levels

Consistently positive customer feedback is a strong indicator of a brand’s reliability. Comparing consumer reviews for both Simonton and Milgard can offer insights into real-world experiences with their products and services.

Making the Right Choice for Your Home

  • Factors to consider based on individual needs

Your choice between Simonton and Milgard should consider factors like energy efficiency, aesthetic preferences, budget, and installation timelines.

  • Recommendations for different types of homes
  • For energy efficiency and modern designs: Milgard.
  • For a balance of cost and variety: Simonton.
  • Final thoughts on selecting the right brand

The decision between Simonton and Milgard hinges on your specific needs and preferences. Both brands offer quality and reliability, but your unique requirements will dictate the best choice for your home.

Read Also: Lindsay Windows vs Andersen Windows? A Comparison


In this comparison of Simonton vs Milgard windows, we’ve navigated through various aspects, from heritage and product offerings to energy efficiency and customer service.

Choosing the right window brand is more than a purchase; it’s an investment in your home’s comfort, aesthetics, and energy efficiency.

Whether you lean towards Simonton’s affordability and variety or Milgard’s energy efficiency and design diversity, the decision ultimately hinges on your specific needs.

Both brands stand tall in the industry, each offering unique benefits to enhance your living spaces.