Home » Door and Windows » Weather Shield Windows vs Andersen – Essential Comparison
Weather Shield Windows vs Andersen - Essential Comparison

Weather Shield Windows vs Andersen – Essential Comparison

by Steven Wilson

In the competitive landscape of windows and doors, Weather Shield Windows vs Andersen stand out as industry titans.

Weather Shield, a family-run business for over 55 years, is celebrated for its high energy efficiency and quality in wood and aluminum products. Andersen, with its 155-year legacy, is recognized for durable, energy-efficient designs and pioneering innovations.

This article delves into a detailed comparison between these two brands, unraveling their key innovations, market positions, and unique offerings.

By understanding their distinct histories and contributions to the industry, we can better discern which brand aligns with your specific home needs.

Let’s explore what sets Weather Shield and Andersen apart.

Weather Shield Windows vs Andersen: Quick Comparison

FeatureWeather ShieldAndersen
Company BackgroundFamily-run since 1955, specializing in all-wood and aluminum windows and doorsEstablished 1903, known for durable and well-designed doors and windows
MarketingFocus on product qualityStrong brand recognition through effective marketing
Key FeaturesEnergy efficiency, durability, variety in hardware and colorsEnergy efficiency, high-performance glass, various styles
Performance DataU-Factor: Variable, Design Pressure: LC-PG50-H (~173mph), Air Infiltration: 0.12 cfmU-Factor: Variable, Design Pressure: LC-PG30 (~131mph), Air Infiltration: <0.30 cfm
Product LineWide range, including specialty and historic designsBroad range of window and door styles
CustomizationSignature Series offers extensive color and wood options400 Series limited to specific colors and wood options
Frame MaterialsWood, aluminum-clad wood, vinyl, fiberglassWood, Fibrex composite, vinyl
Exterior MaterialExtruded aluminum clad with AAMA 2605 finishVinyl clad frame with Fibrex sill
Glass OptionsDouble/triple pane, Low E, high wind resistanceDouble/triple pane, Low E, insulated glass
Energy EfficiencyENERGY STAR compliant, efficient designsENERGY STAR compliant, high-performance glass
Styles and AestheticsFocus on historic accuracy for old homesContemporary styles, smart home integration
Balance SystemAAMA class 3 with stainless steelAAMA class 2 with nylon string
TechnologyTwo operating sashes, integrated nail finVerilock security sensors, wireless sensors
WarrantiesLifetime for vinyl, 20 years for glass/partsLifetime for vinyl, 20 years for glass, 10 years for parts
Manufacturing LocationMedford, WisconsinBayport, Minnesota
Service ReputationMixed, varies by dealerGenerally positive, company-backed support
Lead TimesLengthy for custom windowsLengthy during peak seasons
Price RangeWindows: $160-$1000, Doors: $500-$7000Windows: $400-$1000, Doors: $1870-$8170
Design FlexibilitySpecializes in historic designsLarger window sizes, smart home options
Additional ConsiderationsIndependent dealer installationIn-house certified installation
Pros and ConsPros: Wide selection, strong warranties, historic restorations; Cons: Longer lead times, limited tech optionsPros: Broad product selection, smart features, strong customer service; Cons: Style may not suit historic homes, higher costs for custom windows

Overview of Weather Shield Windows

Weather Shield has steadily evolved over its 55-year journey, establishing itself as a notable player in the windows and doors industry.

This section explores the brand’s evolution, key features, and technological strides.

The Evolution and Specialties of Weather Shield

Weather Shield began as a family-run business and has maintained its commitment to quality and innovation. Their focus has always been on creating products that blend functionality with aesthetic appeal.

Specializing in all-wood and extruded aluminum windows and doors, Weather Shield has tailored its offerings to meet diverse architectural needs, from modern to traditional homes.

Read Also: ProVia Endure vs Aspect Windows – Choose Right

Core Features and Unique Selling Points

What sets Weather Shield apart are its core features:

  • Energy Efficiency: Their products are designed for high energy efficiency, helping to reduce heating and cooling costs.
  • Durability: Emphasis on long-lasting materials ensures that their windows and doors stand the test of time.
  • Quiet Operation: Features like lifetime lubrication and stainless steel springs contribute to a seamless user experience.
  • Customization: A wide range of jambs, interior wood options, hardware finishes, and exterior colors allows for personalized design choices.

Material and Design Diversity in Weather Shield Products

Weather Shield’s product range is a testament to their commitment to diversity in materials and design.

They offer:

  • Various Materials: Choices include wood, aluminum-clad wood, vinyl, and fiberglass, catering to different aesthetic and functional preferences.
  • Design Options: Their portfolio includes single hung, double hung, casement, and specialty windows, among others, offering solutions for various architectural styles.

Energy Efficiency and Technological Advancements

Energy efficiency is at the heart of Weather Shield’s product design.

Their windows and doors come with:

  • Low U-Factors: Ensuring better thermal insulation.
  • Advanced Glass Options: Low E glass contributes to energy savings and comfort.
  • Technological Innovations: With features like lower sash operation and extensive molding choices, Weather Shield integrates technology seamlessly into their designs.

Note: Weather Shield’s approach to energy efficiency not only aligns with modern sustainability demands but also offers cost savings in the long run.

By blending traditional craftsmanship with modern technology, Weather Shield has carved a niche for itself. Their commitment to quality, customization, and energy efficiency makes them a strong contender in the market.

Overview of Andersen Windows

Andersen’s 155-year history in the industry is a story of innovation and excellence.

This section highlights their journey, key features, energy efficiency, and technological advancements.

The Journey of Andersen in the Industry

Andersen’s history is marked by continuous innovation and a commitment to quality.

Since its establishment in 1903, Andersen has become a household name in the windows and doors market, recognized for its durable and energy-efficient products.

The brand’s longevity and sustained success are testaments to its ability to adapt and evolve with changing market trends and customer needs.

Highlighting Andersen’s Key Product Features

Andersen’s products are known for:

  • Durability: Using materials like Fibrex composite, which offer longevity and weather resistance.
  • Design Diversity: A wide range of styles, including contemporary and traditional designs, caters to various architectural preferences.
  • Customization: Options for different glass types, hardware styles, and finishes, allowing for personalized design solutions.

Andersen’s Approach to Energy Efficiency and Sustainability

Energy efficiency is a cornerstone of Andersen’s product design, featuring:

  • High-Performance Glass: Various glass options that optimize energy use.
  • Effective Insulation: Enhanced weather stripping and thermally efficient frame designs to reduce energy loss.
  • Sustainability: Commitment to environmentally responsible manufacturing processes.

Technological Integrations and Style Offerings

Andersen combines technology with style through:

  • Smart Home Technology: Integrations that offer enhanced security and convenience.
  • Aesthetic Flexibility: Options ranging from sleek, modern designs to more classic styles.

Important Note: Andersen’s integration of smart home technology not only modernizes their offerings but also adds an extra layer of convenience and security to their products.

Andersen’s long-standing presence in the industry is backed by its ability to offer durable, energy-efficient, and technologically advanced windows and doors.

With a focus on customer-centric designs and sustainable practices, Andersen continues to be a leader in the windows and doors market.

Key Comparison: Weather Shield Windows vs Andersen Windows

In this section, we delve into a head-to-head comparison between Weather Shield Windows vs Andersen, focusing on their product variety, performance, aesthetics, pricing, and warranties.

Comparing Product Lines and Variety

Weather Shield and Andersen both offer an extensive range of window and door styles.

However, there are nuances in their offerings:

  • Weather Shield: Specializes in a broad spectrum including single hung, double hung, casement, and specialty windows.
  • Andersen: Also presents a wide array but with a focus on larger window sizes and smart home options.

Detailed Comparison of Performance Data

Performance is key in choosing the right window or door.

Here’s how they stack up:

Performance AspectWeather ShieldAndersen
U-FactorVariable based on optionsVariable based on options
Design PressureLC-PG50-H, ~173mphLC-PG30, ~131mph
Air Infiltration0.12 cfmLess than 0.30 cfm

Aesthetic Styles: Historical Accuracy vs. Modern Designs

The aesthetic appeal is a major deciding factor:

  • Weather Shield: Known for historically accurate designs, ideal for traditional or older homes.
  • Andersen: Offers contemporary and sleek styles, suitable for modern homes and those seeking smart home integration.

Pricing, Warranties, and Service Reputation

Cost and after-sales service are critical considerations:

  • Pricing: Both brands have similar pricing structures, but specific costs can vary based on materials and customizations.
  • Warranties: Weather Shield offers a lifetime warranty for vinyl products and 20 years for glass and parts. Andersen also provides a lifetime warranty on vinyl products, with 20 years for glass and 10 years for parts.
  • Service Reputation: Weather Shield’s service can be mixed, depending on the dealer. Andersen generally has positive reviews, with strong company-backed support.

Note: While both brands have their strengths, the choice often boils down to specific needs like design preferences, performance requirements, and budget constraints.

This comparison provides a clear picture of how Weather Shield Windows vs Andersen stand against each other, helping you make an informed decision based on your unique requirements.

Which is Better? Weather Shield or Andersen

Choosing between Weather Shield Windows vs Andersen depends on specific needs and preferences.

This section aims to guide you through making a choice that best fits your architectural style, budget, and quality expectations.

Assessing the Best Fit for Different Architectural Needs

Both brands cater to different architectural styles:

  • Weather Shield: Ideal for those restoring or living in historic homes, offering historically accurate designs.
  • Andersen: Perfect for modern constructions, providing contemporary styles and smart home integrations.

Analyzing Customer Satisfaction and Service Quality

The level of satisfaction and service quality are key differentiators:

  • Weather Shield: Varies depending on the local dealer, with some mixed reviews.
  • Andersen: Generally receives high marks for customer service, backed by strong company support.

Price-Performance Ratio: Making the Cost-Effective Choice

Consider the value for money each brand offers:

  • Weather Shield: Offers a wide selection with strong warranties, but may have longer lead times.
  • Andersen: Known for its broad product selection and smart home features, though it may be more costly for custom options.

Final Recommendations Based on Specific Requirements

Making the final choice should be based on your unique needs:

  • Historic Homes: Weather Shield is the go-to for maintaining historical integrity.
  • Modern and Tech-Savvy Homes: Andersen is more suitable for contemporary designs and those desiring smart home technology.

Important Note: Both Weather Shield and Andersen meet ENERGY STAR standards, ensuring energy efficiency regardless of your choice.

In conclusion, whether Weather Shield or Andersen is better for you hinges on your architectural style, need for customer service, budget, and specific window and door requirements.

By weighing these factors against what each brand excels in, you can make a well-informed decision that aligns with your home improvement goals.

Read Also: Alliance Windows vs Pella – The Definitive Comparison


In our journey through the nuances of Weather Shield Windows vs Andersen, we’ve uncovered their strengths and distinctions.

Looking ahead, we can expect further innovations in energy efficiency and smart technology in windows and doors. The choice between Weather Shield and Andersen ultimately hinges on your specific needs and architectural style.

Remember, the best decision is one that aligns with your personal preferences, home’s character, and lifestyle requirements.

As we embrace future advancements, let your individual needs guide your choice in this ever-evolving market.