Home » Cabinets » Allen and Roth Cabinets vs KraftMaid – Compare and Choose
Allen and Roth Cabinets vs KraftMaid - Compare and Choose

Allen and Roth Cabinets vs KraftMaid – Compare and Choose

by Jessica Miller

When it comes to Allen and Roth Cabinets vs KraftMaid, the choice can be overwhelming. Your kitchen deserves not just any cabinet but the one that complements its style while offering functionality.

This blog post aims to guide you through the key differences between these two well-known brands, to help you make an informed decision. We will dive deeper into materials, finishes, types, and even pricing.

So, if you’re navigating the world of kitchen cabinets, let’s explore which brand offers the solutions you need.

Quick Compare

FeatureAllen and RothKraftMaid
MaterialsMix of woods and laminatesExclusively wood
Finishing SystemTuffTechDuraKraft Plus
Design and BuildBase designClassic design
TypesEssential, Select, LuxuryCustom, Semi-custom, Stock
Door StyleShaker styleShaker and Arched styles
Color OptionsWhite, Blue, Green, BrownBrown, Blue, Gray, White
Drawer SlidesBall-bearing slides90-lb drawer slides
QualityGood, KCMA standardsExcellent, high-quality
DurabilityModerate, heavy-duty plywoodLong-lasting, solid wood
PriceMore affordableGenerally more expensive
ProsAffordable, Simple, Easy assemblyHigh-quality, Large selection
ConsLess durable, Limited styleMore expensive, Longer lead times

Key Features and Specifications

The core appeal of any cabinet lies in its features and specifications. This section dissects the essential elements such as materials, finishes, and designs of Allen and Roth Cabinets or KraftMaid.

Materials Used by Each Brand

Allen and Roth

  • Solid Wood: Known for durability and classic appeal.
  • Plywood: Offers a balance between price and performance.
  • MDF: Ideal for painted finishes due to its smooth surface.


  • Hardwood: Notable for its robustness and long-lasting nature.
  • Plywood: A go-to material for those seeking both quality and affordability.
  • Particle Board: Economical but less durable.

Note: Choosing the right material is crucial as it not only affects durability but also the overall look and feel of the cabinets.

Types of Finishing Systems

Allen and Roth

  • Lacquer Finish: Glossy and modern appearance.
  • Stain Finish: Adds depth and character to wood grains.


  • Catalyzed Conversion Varnish: Resistant to water and chemical damage.
  • Natural Oil Finish: Provides a traditional look.

Design and Build Comparison

Both brands showcase impressive craftsmanship, yet they have distinct approaches:

  • Allen and Roth: Emphasizes clean lines and modern aesthetics.
  • KraftMaid: Focuses on a mix of traditional and contemporary styles.

Design and Build Features

FeatureAllen and RothKraftMaid
Soft-Close DrawersStandardOptional
Corner SolutionsLimitedExtensive

Range of Types and Styles Offered

Allen and Roth

  • Wall Cabinets
  • Base Cabinets
  • Full-Height Cabinets


  • Wall Cabinets
  • Base Cabinets
  • Pantry Cabinets
  • Specialty Units

Note: The range of types and styles significantly influences the functionality and aesthetics of your kitchen.

This section has provided a comprehensive look at the key features and specifications, laying the groundwork for a more informed decision between Allen and Roth Cabinets vs KraftMaid.

Read Also: Starmark Cabinets vs KraftMaid – Which is the Perfect Fit?

Key Differences

Identifying the key differences between Allen and Roth Cabinets and KraftMaid is vital for making an informed choice. This section delves into aspects such as price, drawer mechanisms, color options, and durability.

Price Points and What They Include

Allen and Roth

  • Economical Range: Starts at $200 per unit
  • Mid-Range: Around $400 per unit
  • Premium: Exceeds $800 per unit


  • Budget-Friendly: Starts at $150 per unit
  • Mid-Range: Ranges from $300 to $600
  • High-End: Can go up to $1,200 per unit

Note: Always consider what is included in the price such as hardware, finishes, and additional features like soft-close drawers.

Drawer Slide Mechanisms and Their Benefits

Allen and Roth

  • Ball-bearing Slides: Allows for smooth and quiet operation.
  • Soft-Close Feature: Standard in most models.


  • Undermount Slides: Concealed and provide full drawer extension.
  • Soft-Close Feature: Optional but highly recommended.

Drawer Slide Mechanisms

MechanismAllen and RothKraftMaid
Ball-bearingStandardNot Available
UndermountNot AvailableStandard

Color Options and Customizability

Allen and Roth

  • Offers around 20 standard color options.
  • Limited customizability.


  • Provides over 50 standard colors.
  • High customizability including mix and match options.

Quality and Durability Metrics

Allen and Roth

  • Typically offers a 5-year warranty.
  • Known for solid build and reliable finishes.


  • Generally provides a lifetime warranty.
  • Renowned for high-quality hardwood and durable finishes.

Note: Paying attention to warranty periods can offer insights into the expected longevity of the product.

This section has addressed the critical differences between Allen and Roth Cabinets and KraftMaid, making your choice an informed one.

Which is Better and Why

Determining the superior choice between Allen and Roth Cabinets vs KraftMaid is the focal point of this section. Various factors like pros and cons, decision-making variables, and ultimate recommendations are covered.

Pros and Cons for Each Brand

Pros and Cons Comparison

FactorAllen and RothKraftMaid
Pros– Economical– Highly Customizable
– Durable Finish– Wide Range of Styles
– 5-Year Warranty– Lifetime Warranty
Cons– Limited Customization– Higher Cost
– Fewer Styles– Complexity in Ordering

Decision Factors to Consider

  • Budget: Allen and Roth offers more budget-friendly options.
  • Customization: KraftMaid excels in customization features.
  • Warranty: Long-term warranty options are available with KraftMaid.
  • Design Variety: KraftMaid provides a wider array of styles.

Note: Align your priorities with these factors to make an informed decision.

Overall Recommendations Based on Different Needs

  • Budget-Conscious Consumers: Allen and Roth Cabinets are the ideal choice.
  • Design Aficionados: KraftMaid offers greater customization and design options.
  • Long-Term Investment: KraftMaid’s lifetime warranty could be more beneficial.

Answering the Ultimate Question—Which Is Better

Both brands have their unique strengths and weaknesses. If budget constraints and durability are your primary concerns, Allen and Roth would be a suitable choice. On the other hand, if you are looking for extensive customization and are prepared for a higher upfront cost, KraftMaid proves to be the better option.

Through a balanced evaluation, this section aims to guide you toward the cabinet brand that will best meet your needs.

Read Also: Medallion Cabinets vs Kraftmaid – An Impressive Showdown


We’ve taken a detailed look at Allen and Roth Cabinets vs KraftMaid, examining their key features, differences, and overall benefits. The objective is to guide you through the process of making an informed decision.

Based on our analysis, Allen and Roth is ideal for those on a budget who prioritize durability, while KraftMaid stands out for its customization options and comprehensive warranty.

Both brands offer valuable choices; your ultimate selection should align with your individual needs and preferences. The next steps involve reaching out to vendors, comparing prices, and perhaps visiting showrooms to experience the products first-hand.