Home » Furniture » American Signature vs Ashley Furniture – Your Definitive Guide
American Signature vs Ashley Furniture - Your Definitive Guide

American Signature vs Ashley Furniture – Your Definitive Guide

by Ethan Ross

The debate between American Signature vs Ashley Furniture has long piqued the interest of consumers looking for quality, style, and affordability in home furnishings. But why should one even bother to compare the two?

The simple answer is that furnishing your home is not only a significant financial commitment, but it also has a lasting impact on your living space.

By understanding what each brand excels at, you can make an informed decision tailored to your specific needs and preferences.

This article aims to provide a thorough comparison between the two esteemed brands, covering everything from their history and geographic presence to pricing and warranty policies.

Comparing Table

CriteriaAshley FurnitureAmerican Signature
Founded1945, Chicago, IL1948, Ohio
Locations800+ showrooms globally, 129 countries120+ storefronts in 19 U.S. states
Online SalesYesYes
Furniture TypesIndoor, Outdoor, Bedroom, Kids Room, PatioIndoor, Outdoor, Bedroom, Kids Room, Patio
StylesClassic, Modern, Urban, Farmhouse, etc.Classic, Modern, Urban, Farmhouse, etc.
Sales and DiscountsSeasonal and clearance itemsSeasonal and clearance items
ShippingGlobal, free standard shipping in contiguous U.S.Primarily local, free shipping on select orders
Assembly ServiceVia company’s carrier service or local showroomsMay offer in-home assembly for eligible items
Warranty1 to 5 years, varies by product5-year Pure Promise, specific to types

Historical Background

The origins and growth trajectories of American Signature and Ashley Furniture offer valuable insights into what these brands bring to the table. Understanding their historical background can shed light on the brand’s philosophies, which, in turn, can influence a customer’s choice.

Origin of Ashley Furniture and its Growth

Ashley Furniture’s history traces back to 1945, when it was founded in Chicago, Illinois. Initially, it was a modest venture, but over the years, it has expanded impressively.

Today, Ashley Furniture stands as a global enterprise with over 800 showrooms spread across 129 countries. A key driver of this phenomenal growth has been the brand’s focus on variety and quality, targeting a broad demographic range.

Note: Ashley Furniture is one of the world’s top home furniture brands, not just in terms of reach but also in terms of product diversity.

The Rise of American Signature

Much like Ashley, American Signature has its roots deeply implanted in the mid-20th century. Established in Ohio in 1948, it may not have the global presence of its counterpart, but it holds a firm footing in the United States.

With over 120 storefronts concentrated in 19 states, particularly in the Midwest, Southeast, and East Coast, American Signature has garnered a dedicated following.

Market Presence for Both Companies

While both companies started around the same time and share a focus on affordable yet stylish furniture, their market presence varies.

  • Ashley Furniture
    • Global Reach
    • Diverse Product Portfolio
    • Strong Online Presence
  • American Signature
    • Strong U.S. Presence
    • Focus on Specific Regions
    • Primarily Physical Storefronts

Both brands have made significant strides in capturing market share but in different scopes and scales. Ashley has a broader customer base, while American Signature’s influence is more region-specific within the U.S.

Understanding their market presence can be vital in assessing how accessible each brand is to you, depending on your geographic location.

Geographic Presence and Accessibility

One of the most critical factors influencing the consumer’s choice between American Signature or Ashley Furniture is how accessible these brands are, depending on where you live. Accessibility not only includes physical stores but also extends to online platforms, making it easier for you to shop from the comfort of your home.

Number of Physical Showrooms for Ashley Furniture

Ashley Furniture has significantly expanded its global footprint. With over 800 showrooms worldwide, the brand makes it easy for customers to walk into a store almost anywhere and explore their extensive product range.

Whether you are located in Europe, Asia, or North America, chances are you can find an Ashley Furniture showroom near you.

American Signature’s Dominance in Specific Regions

On the other hand, American Signature primarily operates in the United States. It has more than 120 stores in 19 states, with a strong presence particularly in the Midwest, Southeast, and East Coast regions. While it might not offer the global reach that Ashley Furniture does, American Signature serves its targeted U.S. markets exceedingly well.

Note: American Signature specializes in specific regions, providing a tailored shopping experience for local customers.

Online Platforms and Their Reach

While both brands have an online shopping interface, Ashley Furniture has a stronger global online presence, making it accessible to customers from 129 countries. American Signature, meanwhile, focuses on the U.S. market, aligning with its physical store locations.

  • Ashley Furniture
    • Ships globally
    • Offers free standard shipping within the contiguous U.S.
  • American Signature
    • Ships only within the U.S.
    • Provides free shipping on select orders

Both brands have invested in creating user-friendly online platforms, but Ashley Furniture provides broader access for customers outside of the United States.

Read Also: Pottery Barn vs Restoration Hardware – Make the Right Choice

Variety and Range of Furniture Collections

Both American Signature vs Ashley Furniture offer a wide array of furniture collections that cater to diverse customer needs. The breadth of their offerings goes beyond indoor living and dining room sets to include outdoor furniture and specialized sets for children and patios. Here, we detail the extent of their collections, segmenting them into indoor, outdoor, and specialty ranges.

Types of Indoor Furniture Available

Ashley Furniture offers a more extensive range of indoor furniture options, including sofas, dining sets, bedroom furniture, and office desks. American Signature also has a wide variety but tends to focus on classic American styles.

TypeAshley FurnitureAmerican Signature
Living Room SetsYesYes
Dining Room SetsYesYes
Bedroom FurnitureYesYes
Office DesksYesLimited Availability

Outdoor Furniture Choices

When it comes to outdoor furniture, Ashley Furniture takes the lead with an array of choices ranging from simple patio sets to luxurious poolside lounges. American Signature, however, has a limited selection in this category, primarily aimed at budget-conscious consumers.

  • Ashley Furniture
    • Patio Sets
    • Poolside Lounges
    • Outdoor Dining Tables
  • American Signature
    • Basic Patio Sets

Note: If you’re looking for a broader variety of outdoor furniture, Ashley Furniture is likely a better fit for your needs.

Special Collections for Kids and Patios

Both brands offer specialized collections catering to children’s rooms and patios. Ashley Furniture offers thematic sets like “Disney Princess” for kids, while American Signature focuses on functional furniture that grows with your child, such as convertible cribs.

  • Ashley Furniture
    • Disney Princess Sets
    • Sports-Themed Furniture
  • American Signature
    • Convertible Cribs
    • Study Tables

Each brand has distinct strengths, whether you are furnishing your living room, setting up an outdoor space, or designing a child’s room. Your choice may ultimately come down to specific needs and aesthetic preferences.

Styles and Aesthetics

The choice between American Signature vs Ashley Furniture often extends beyond functionality to the domain of design and aesthetics. Both brands offer a range of stylistic categories, allowing customers to select pieces that resonate with their personal tastes. From the design philosophies that guide each brand to the common and unique attributes that set them apart, this section will cover all these angles.

Stylistic Categories Offered by Ashley Furniture

Ashley Furniture is known for its diverse selection of styles, offering everything from traditional to contemporary designs. Their collections are often categorized as follows:

  • Rustic
  • Vintage
  • Modern
  • Traditional
  • Contemporary
RusticNatural elements, warm tones
VintageNostalgic pieces with antique finish
ModernSleek lines, minimalist
TraditionalRich woods, intricate designs
ContemporaryUpdated takes on classic designs

American Signature’s Design Philosophy

American Signature takes a more focused approach, primarily emphasizing classic American styles. Their guiding principle is to provide timeless pieces that are both practical and aesthetically pleasing. Their signature styles often include:

  • Farmhouse
  • Colonial
  • Shaker
  • Craftsman

Note: If you prefer classic American styles, American Signature’s design philosophy may be more aligned with your preferences.

Common and Unique Style Attributes

While both brands offer traditional and modern options, their unique attributes set them apart. Ashley Furniture, for instance, offers extensive customization options. American Signature, on the other hand, focuses on durability and heirloom-quality pieces.

  • Ashley Furniture: Customization options, broad color palette
  • American Signature: Durable materials, timeless designs

In terms of aesthetics and style, both brands provide ample options to fulfill diverse customer needs, from those seeking modern flair to those who appreciate classic beauty. Your choice will largely depend on your stylistic preference and the specific design elements you wish to incorporate into your space.

Pricing, Sales, and Promotions

Decisions about furnishing one’s home are often influenced by cost. To better inform your decision between American Signature and Ashley Furniture, this section addresses the financial aspects, from regular pricing metrics to seasonal sales and how to make savvy selections.

Regular Pricing Metrics for Both Brands

The pricing metrics vary between the two brands. Here’s a comparison table to give you a quick overview:

Furniture TypeAshley Furniture ($)American Signature ($)
Dining Set300-1800400-2000
Bedroom Set700-3000800-3500
Coffee Table150-800200-900

Ashley Furniture typically offers a broader range of pricing options, accommodating a variety of budgets. American Signature, on the other hand, tends to position itself in a slightly higher price bracket, emphasizing quality and longevity.

Seasonal Sales and Discount Events

Both American Signature and Ashley Furniture offer numerous seasonal sales and promotions throughout the year:

  • Black Friday
  • Cyber Monday
  • Memorial Day
  • Fourth of July
  • Labor Day

Note: It’s advisable to sign up for their newsletters to receive timely notifications about upcoming sales events.

How to Make Cost-Effective Choices

When looking for ways to economize while still obtaining quality furniture, consider the following steps:

  1. Compare Prices Online: Both brands have user-friendly websites that allow for easy price comparisons.
  2. Use Coupons: Websites and apps often provide digital coupons that can yield additional savings.
  3. Attend Sales Events: Seasonal sales events often provide the opportunity for substantial savings.

Overall, American Signature tends to appeal to those seeking long-term investments, while Ashley Furniture offers a range of options for those on a tighter budget. It’s essential to plan your purchases around sales events and consider using digital coupons to optimize savings.

Shipping, Delivery, and Warranty

Bringing home that perfect piece of furniture is a multi-step process, part of which involves shipping, delivery, and of course, the peace of mind that comes from warranty coverage. Let’s compare these facets between American Signature vs Ashley Furniture to determine which might suit your needs.

Shipping Methods and Free Shipping Policies

Both companies offer multiple shipping methods. The most common options include standard shipping, expedited shipping, and white-glove delivery service. Below is a comparative table outlining their policies:

Ashley FurnitureAmerican Signature
Standard Shipping$50-$100$75-$125
Expedited Shipping$100-$200$125-$225
White-Glove Delivery$200-$400$250-$450
Free Shipping PolicyOrders above $1000Orders above $1500

Assembly Services Provided

Assembly services differ between the two brands:

  • Ashley Furniture: Offers optional assembly service for an additional fee of $50-$150 depending on the item.
  • American Signature: Provides complimentary assembly for select furniture pieces.

Note: Always clarify assembly policies at the time of purchase to avoid surprises.

Warranty Plans and Their Limitations

Ashley Furniture offers:

  1. Limited Lifetime Warranty on frame and springs.
  2. Five-year warranty on leather and cushions.
  3. One-year warranty on fabric and labor.

American Signature offers:

  1. Lifetime warranty on frame and springs.
  2. Seven-year warranty on cushions.
  3. Five-year warranty on leather and fabric.

Warranty plans can be a critical deciding factor. Always read the fine print to understand the limitations and inclusions. American Signature offers slightly more extended warranties, which may be a point of consideration for your purchase.

Read Also: King Hickory vs Ethan Allen – Honest Comparison


After comparing the nuances of American Signature vs Ashley Furniture, it’s evident that each has its unique offerings and limitations. If warranty and assembly services are priorities, American Signature could be your go-to choice.

For those seeking more affordable shipping options and a broader range of styles, Ashley Furniture stands out. With this analysis, we aim to guide you towards making an informed decision tailored to your specific needs.