Home » Furniture » Ashley Furniture vs Value City Furniture – Make the Right Decision
Ashley Furniture vs Value City Furniture - Make the Right Decision

Ashley Furniture vs Value City Furniture – Make the Right Decision

by Ethan Ross

Choosing between Ashley Furniture vs Value City Furniture can be a daunting task given their longstanding reputations and diverse offerings. Recognizing the importance of furnishing your space with pieces that resonate with your style and needs, this comparison will serve as a comprehensive guide.

We’ll delve into various aspects such as locations, selection, delivery options, warranty policies, style variants, and outdoor offerings.

The objective here is to arm you with all the facts and insights needed to make an informed decision on where to invest in quality furniture for your home.

Historical Background and Market Presence

Navigating the histories and market presence of Ashley Furniture and Value City Furniture provides essential insights into their respective growth strategies and consumer reach.

Let’s break down how each of these brands evolved over the years and what makes them significant players in the furniture market today.

Establishment and Growth of Ashley Furniture

Founded in 1945, Ashley Furniture has become a household name and one of the largest furniture vendors worldwide. Over the years, the brand has expanded its operations to include not only a vast network of Ashley HomeStore locations but also 15 manufacturing and distribution centers.

Note: Ashley Furniture’s massive manufacturing capacity allows it to offer a diverse range of furniture styles and customization options.

Establishment and Growth of Value City Furniture

Value City Furniture, which is owned by American Signature, opened its doors in 1948. Though it operates fewer stores than Ashley, it has cultivated a strong following, primarily in the Midwest, East Coast, and Southeast states of the United States.

Geographic Locations Served by Each Brand

  • Ashley Furniture: Over 1,000 stores worldwide
  • Value City Furniture: More than 120 stores in targeted regions

While Ashley Furniture boasts a more extensive global reach, Value City Furniture specializes in serving specific geographic locales, offering delivery only from local showrooms.

Current Market Influence and Brand Recognition

Ashley Furniture has a more global footprint, underscored by thousands of retail partners offering Ashley brand products. On the other hand, Value City Furniture focuses on a localized approach, providing a more personalized customer experience.

Both brands have leveraged social media and online platforms to expand their reach, offer promotions, and engage with a younger audience. Their strong market influence is not merely the result of their extensive history but also their adaptability to modern retailing techniques.

Range and Diversity of Furniture Selection

When it comes to outfitting your living space, both Ashley Furniture and Value City Furniture present a wealth of options.

This section aims to dissect the range and diversity of furniture each brand offers, from types and styles to exclusive collections and commonalities between the two.

Types of Furniture Offered by Ashley Furniture

Ashley Furniture provides a one-stop-shop experience for all your home furnishing needs.

Their product line includes:

  • Living Room Furniture
  • Dining Room Sets
  • Bedroom Collections
  • Kids’ Furniture
  • Home Office Essentials
  • Patio Sets
  • Decor Items
  • Mattresses

Note: Ashley Furniture also provides various mattress options, giving customers the added advantage of outfitting an entire bedroom in one go.

Types of Furniture Offered by Value City Furniture

Value City Furniture also covers the gamut of home furnishings but places additional emphasis on accents to complement their furniture sets.

Their offerings include:

  • Living and Dining Room Sets
  • Bedroom Furniture
  • Children’s Furniture
  • Home Office Pieces
  • Outdoor Furniture
  • Decor Accents

Exclusive Collections and Customization Options

Both Ashley and Value City Furniture offer exclusive collections that bring unique styles to the table. Ashley Furniture often collaborates with designers to offer limited-edition lines, while Value City Furniture focuses on themes designed in-house or through partnerships with interior designers.

Common Grounds: What Both Offer

In spite of their unique selling propositions, both brands do have overlapping product categories:

Common OfferingsAshley FurnitureValue City Furniture
Living Room FurnitureYesYes
Dining Room SetsYesYes
Bedroom FurnitureYesYes
Children’s FurnitureYesYes
Home Office FurnitureYesYes
Patio SetsYesYes

Both Ashley Furniture and Value City Furniture offer extensive selections in these categories, leaving you with a plethora of options to adorn your home.

Read Also: England Furniture vs Ashley Furniture Uncovered Furniture Truths

A Comprehensive Look at Delivery Services

The logistics behind acquiring your ideal furniture piece can be as important as the product itself.

This section provides a meticulous examination of the delivery services offered by Ashley Furniture and Value City Furniture, from their policies to how they handle large deliveries.

Ashley Furniture Delivery Policies

Ashley Furniture offers various delivery options tailored to the needs of its customers.

These include:

  • Standard Shipping: Suitable for small items like home decor.
  • Doorstep Delivery: Larger items are delivered to your doorstep but not installed.
  • Room of Choice: Items are delivered and placed in your desired room.
  • Full-Service Delivery: Includes setup and assembly of furniture.

Note: Charges for these services vary depending on location and the complexity of the order.

Value City Furniture Delivery Policies

Value City Furniture provides a somewhat simpler yet effective array of delivery services:

  • Free Store Pickup: Allows customers to pick up items from the nearest store.
  • Direct Shipping: For smaller items, sent directly to your doorstep.
  • White Glove Service: Includes full assembly and room placement.

Free Shipping Offers and Limitations

Both brands occasionally offer promotions that include free shipping, but limitations often apply.

For example, Ashley Furniture typically offers free shipping on smaller items and decor, while Value City often runs seasonal promotions that include free “White Glove” delivery service for furniture sets over a certain price.

BrandFree Shipping on Small ItemsFree Shipping on Large Items
Ashley FurnitureOccasionallyRarely
Value City FurnitureRarelyOccasionally

How Each Brand Handles Large Deliveries

When it comes to the logistics of large deliveries, Ashley Furniture often uses third-party services, requiring coordination between multiple parties.

On the other hand, Value City Furniture manages its own fleet, resulting in a more seamless, though occasionally slower, delivery process.

Both companies offer tracking systems for large deliveries, ensuring that you are not left in the dark about the arrival of your new furniture. By understanding the delivery policies of each brand, you are better equipped to make an informed decision.

Warranty Policies and Customer Protections

When investing in furniture, the assurance of quality and longevity plays a pivotal role.

In this section, we delve into the warranty policies and customer protections offered by Ashley Furniture vs Value City Furniture. Understanding the nuances of these policies will aid you in making an informed purchasing decision.

Ashley Furniture’s Approach to Warranties

Ashley Furniture offers a diversified range of warranties, depending on the type of furniture you buy.

Their categories include:

  • Limited Lifetime Warranty: Covers frame and spring unit defects.
  • 5-Year Warranty: Protection against fabric, cushion, and electrical components.
  • 1-Year Warranty: Coverage for finishing and parts.

Note: Warranties often require the purchase to be made directly from Ashley Furniture or an authorized dealer.

Value City Furniture’s Warranty Offerings

Unlike Ashley Furniture, Value City Furniture takes a more streamlined approach to warranties:

  • Standard Warranty: Most furniture comes with a one-year limited warranty covering manufacturing defects.
  • Extended Warranty Options: Additional coverage can be purchased, extending the warranty for up to five years.

Coverage Specifics: What Is and Isn’t Covered

A pivotal aspect of warranties is what exactly is covered and what is not.

Here is a comparison table to help you navigate the specifics:

CoverageAshley FurnitureValue City Furniture
FrameLimited Lifetime1 Year
Fabric5 YearsNot covered
Electrical Parts5 YearsNot covered
Finish1 YearNot covered
Manufacturing DefectAll warranties1 Year

How to Make a Warranty Claim with Each Brand

Making a warranty claim can be a crucial part of your post-purchase experience.

For Ashley Furniture, claims must be made through their official website, requiring a detailed description and evidence of the issue.

For Value City Furniture, you can either call their customer service or visit the nearest physical store to initiate a claim. Both brands often require proof of purchase and may send an expert for evaluation.

By understanding the warranty landscape of these furniture giants, you equip yourself with the knowledge needed to make a more secure and confident purchase.

Deciphering Style Variants and Themes

Style serves as the canvas on which the beauty and functionality of furniture are painted.

In this section, we examine the core design principles of Ashley Furniture vs Value City Furniture, as well as the versatility in style choices each brand offers.

Making an informed decision between these two giants could hinge on how well their design philosophies resonate with your own aesthetic preferences.

Core Design Principles at Ashley Furniture

Ashley Furniture leans towards a balanced mix of classic and contemporary designs.

Their core principles can be summarized as follows:

  1. Elegance: Smooth lines, intricate patterns, and rich colors dominate the landscape.
  2. Functionality: Utility is not sacrificed for the sake of beauty.
  3. Durability: Designs often incorporate sturdy materials like hardwood and metal.

Note: Ashley Furniture frequently releases collections in collaboration with renowned designers to bring a unique blend of styles to consumers.

Core Design Principles at Value City Furniture

Value City Furniture offers a different approach to design with these principles:

  1. Affordability: Budget-friendly options that don’t compromise on style.
  2. Minimalism: Simplistic designs with a focus on practicality.
  3. Customizability: Offers the possibility to personalize designs, colors, and fabrics.

Versatility in Style Choices

While Ashley Furniture tends to oscillate between classic and modern, Value City Furniture leans more towards minimalistic and customizable designs.

Below is a table summarizing their stylistic versatility:

Style CategoriesAshley FurnitureValue City Furniture

Recommended Styles for Various Home Settings

Based on different home settings, here are our recommendations:

  • For Traditional Homes: Ashley’s classic designs would blend seamlessly.
  • For Modern Apartments: Value City’s contemporary and minimalistic options would be ideal.
  • For DIY Enthusiasts: Value City offers greater room for customization.

Deciding on a style that suits your home environment is a crucial step in the furniture-buying process. Both brands offer compelling options, but your choice should align with the aesthetics you wish to achieve.

Outdoor Furniture Offerings

Outdoor furniture provides more than just seating arrangements; it extends the comfort and style of your interior living space to the outdoors.

This section examines the variety of outdoor furniture available at Ashley Furniture vs Value City Furniture. It also evaluates the durability, weather resistance, and overall value of the outdoor collections these brands offer.

Range of Outdoor Furniture at Ashley Furniture

Ashley Furniture offers an extensive array of outdoor options.

They offer:

  1. Patio sets: Comprising tables, chairs, and even coordinating umbrellas.
  2. Benches and Loungers: Perfect for poolside relaxation.
  3. Outdoor Bars: For those looking to entertain in style.

Note: Ashley Furniture emphasizes pieces that echo the elegance of their indoor collections, creating a cohesive look and feel.

Range of Outdoor Furniture at Value City Furniture

In contrast, Value City Furniture has a more focused selection:

  1. Patio Chairs: Available in a variety of styles and materials.
  2. Side Tables: Complementing the seating options.
  3. Outdoor Sofas: Bringing indoor comfort to the outdoors.

Durability and Weather Resistance Factors

The measure of good outdoor furniture lies not just in design but also in how well it can withstand environmental conditions. Ashley Furniture typically employs hard-wearing materials like treated wood and metal with rust-resistant coatings. Value City Furniture often uses resilient polymers and fabrics that are UV-resistant.

Quality Assessment: Which Brand Offers Better Value

The table below compares the two brands on important metrics:

MetricsAshley FurnitureValue City Furniture
Range of OptionsExtensiveFocused
Weather ResistanceHighModerate
Aesthetic Cohesion with IndoorsYesLimited

Deciding between the two will likely be a function of what you prioritize—whether it’s variety, durability, or aesthetic continuity. Each brand offers compelling choices, but your decision will ultimately be guided by the specifics of what you are seeking in outdoor furniture.

Frequently Asked Questions on Ashley Furniture vs Value City Furniture

How Do Financing Options Differ Between Ashley Furniture and Value City Furniture?

Ashley Furniture offers a variety of financing options including store credit cards with promotional interest rates. Value City Furniture also has its credit card but tends to offer more third-party financing options. The choice between the two may depend on your credit history and financing requirements.

Is Assembly Service Available for Both Brands?

Yes, both brands offer assembly services, but the terms may vary. Ashley Furniture typically includes assembly as part of their premium delivery service, whereas Value City Furniture often charges separately for this service.

Do Both Brands Offer International Shipping?

Neither Ashley Furniture nor Value City Furniture provides international shipping as a standard option. They primarily cater to domestic markets. However, third-party services can facilitate international deliveries.

How Do the Two Brands Fare on Eco-Friendliness?

Ashley Furniture has a robust sustainability program, focusing on renewable materials and waste reduction. Value City Furniture does not publicize a strong focus on sustainability, making Ashley the more eco-conscious choice.

What Types of Fabrics are Commonly Used?

Ashley Furniture often utilizes premium fabrics like leather and performance fabric. Value City Furniture offers a wide range but leans more toward budget-friendly materials like polyester.

Are Extended Warranties Available?

Both brands offer extended warranties but differ in terms and coverage. Ashley Furniture generally provides longer warranty periods, whereas Value City Furniture offers more budget-friendly warranty packages.

Are Swatches Available for Furniture Upholstery?

Yes, both brands offer fabric swatches to help you make an informed decision. They can be ordered online or picked up in-store for your convenience.

How Do Return Policies Compare?

Ashley Furniture generally offers a 30-day return policy with specific conditions. Value City Furniture’s return policy is more stringent, often involving restocking fees and additional charges.

Can I Track My Delivery in Real-Time?

Ashley Furniture offers real-time tracking features for its deliveries. Value City Furniture also provides tracking but may not offer real-time updates, depending on the location and delivery method.

Do They Offer Furniture for Commercial Spaces?

While both brands focus on home furnishings, Ashley Furniture has a specific line designed for commercial spaces. Value City Furniture does not offer such a specialized range but can still provide bulk orders for businesses.

Read Also: How To Choose Between Birch Lane vs Ashley Furniture


The landscape of home furnishings reveals pronounced contrasts and similarities between Ashley Furniture vs Value City Furniture. These range from design aesthetics to delivery policies, making your selection dependent on various factors.

Ashley leans towards premium quality and a wider range of styles, while Value City Furniture offers affordability and utilitarian designs.

Consider your budget, design preferences, and need for additional services like assembly or extended warranties.

For those seeking high-quality and versatile designs, Ashley Furniture is recommended. If budget and basic functionality are key, Value City Furniture should be your choice.

Your choice between these two prominent brands should be guided by a blend of your budget, design preferences, and specific needs like delivery and warranty. Make an informed decision based on these crucial factors.