Home » Furniture » Coleman Furniture vs Ashley Furniture – Unveil the Best
Coleman Furniture vs Ashley Furniture - Unveil the Best

Coleman Furniture vs Ashley Furniture – Unveil the Best

by Ethan Ross

Choosing between Coleman Furniture vs Ashley Furniture can be quite the task given the strengths each brand brings to the table. Whether you’re decorating your living room or planning your outdoor setup, the importance of making the right furniture choice cannot be overstated.

This blog aims to provide you with a comprehensive comparison of these two major furniture brands. By the time you finish reading, you’ll have a solid understanding of their history, product offerings, quality, pricing, and customer policies, equipping you with the information you need to make an informed decision.

Brand History and Origin

Understanding the roots of Coleman Furniture vs Ashley Furniture can offer insights into the companies’ core values, quality standards, and customer service ethics. With this information, customers can make more informed decisions about where to invest their money.

Coleman Furniture: Brief Background and Accomplishments

Coleman Furniture has garnered a reputation for delivering excellent quality furniture right to your doorstep.

Known for punctuality and adherence to high standards, this brand is popular among consumers. It often rolls out special offers and deals, particularly during holiday seasons, making it a go-to option for many.

Note: Coleman Furniture often provides seasonal and holiday promotions, making it an attractive option during those periods.

Ashley Furniture: Founding Year, Founder Names, and Expansion

Ashley Furniture was established in 1945 by Carlyle Weinberger and Ronald G. Ashley. It had humble beginnings in Chicago, Illinois but has since grown exponentially.

Currently, it stands as one of the largest U.S. furniture retailers with over 700 stores and a workforce of 20,000 employees.

  • Over 700 stores
  • 20,000 employees
  • Founded in 1945
  • Founders: Carlyle Weinberger and Ronald G. Ashley

Significance of Brand History in Customer Trust

Brand history plays a pivotal role in building customer trust. It often serves as a testimonial of the quality and service one can expect. A well-established brand generally indicates a proven track record of customer satisfaction and product durability.

Therefore, knowing the background of Coleman and Ashley Furniture can give you more confidence in your purchasing decisions.

Comparative Snapshot: Age and Credibility

Here’s a quick comparison to illustrate the age and credibility of both brands:

BrandYears in BusinessCredibility Markers
Coleman FurnitureNot specifiedKnown for quality and on-time delivery
Ashley Furniture78 yearsLarge scale, variety of products, extensive workforce

While Coleman Furniture excels in quality and punctuality, Ashley Furniture boasts a longstanding history and large scale, potentially instilling more confidence in buyers seeking established brands.

Product Offerings and Categories

Selecting the right furniture involves more than just considering the price or brand reputation; the range of products available is equally crucial. Both Coleman Furniture vs Ashley Furniture have their strengths and specialties in this regard.

Let’s delve into the types of products you can expect from each brand.

Coleman Furniture: Overview of Indoor and Outdoor Products

Coleman Furniture provides an array of products that cater to both your indoor and outdoor needs. From outdoor items like tents, grills, and camp furniture to indoor essentials including kids’ furniture, bathroom sets, and tables, the brand aims to be your one-stop-shop.

  • Outdoor items: Tents, grills, camp furniture
  • Indoor items: Kids’ furniture, bathroom sets, tables

Note: Coleman Furniture offers both indoor and outdoor options, allowing for a more cohesive look throughout your home.

Ashley Furniture: Range from Sofas to Bedroom Sets

Ashley Furniture focuses predominantly on indoor furniture, with a wide selection that includes sofas, loveseats, mattresses, bedroom sets, dining room sets, and living room sets. Among their popular products are the Darcy Loveseat, Zardoni Loveseat, and Nason Manual Reclining Loveseat.

  • Sofas and Loveseats: Darcy Loveseat, Zardoni Loveseat
  • Mattresses, bedroom sets, dining room sets
  • Living room sets, outdoor sets

Focus on Variety: Is More Always Better?

While Coleman Furniture provides a range of both indoor and outdoor items, Ashley Furniture offers an extensive selection strictly focused on indoor furniture. The question that arises is whether a more comprehensive range is necessarily better.

The answer largely depends on individual needs. If you are looking for a brand that caters to both indoor and outdoor spaces, Coleman Furniture may be your preferred choice. On the other hand, if indoor furniture is your sole focus, Ashley Furniture offers a wide array of options.

Comparative Snapshot: Flexibility in Choice

To give a clearer perspective, here’s a comparison table of the product offerings:

BrandIndoor FurnitureOutdoor Furniture
Coleman FurnitureKids’ furniture, bathroom sets, tablesTents, grills, camp furniture
Ashley FurnitureSofas, loveseats, bedroom sets, dining setsLimited outdoor sets

In summary, Coleman Furniture offers more flexibility with indoor and outdoor options, while Ashley Furniture specializes in indoor furniture with a broader range.

Read Also: Who Wins? Badcock vs Ashley Furniture Showdown

Quality and Material Standards

Among the many factors that differentiate Coleman Furniture from Ashley Furniture is their approach to quality and material standards. Consumers often have concerns about durability and longevity when it comes to furniture, making it important to scrutinize the materials used by each brand.

This section will delve into these aspects for both Coleman and Ashley Furniture.

Coleman Furniture: Known Quality Attributes

Coleman Furniture takes a multi-faceted approach to quality. Most of their indoor items, like tables and bedroom sets, employ hard-wearing woods such as mahogany and oak. Their outdoor range, featuring tents and grills, is designed with weather-resistant materials like stainless steel and heavy-duty polyester.

  • Indoor Furniture: Mahogany, oak
  • Outdoor Furniture: Stainless steel, heavy-duty polyester

Note: Coleman Furniture utilizes materials that are specifically suited to the function of each product, whether it’s indoor or outdoor.

Ashley Furniture: Quality Materials and Customer Testimonials

Ashley Furniture is particularly lauded for its use of premium materials in indoor furniture. Whether it’s the high-resilience foam in their sofas or the solid wood in their bedroom sets, quality is a constant. Customer testimonials frequently mention the durability and aesthetic appeal of their products.

  • Upholstery: High-resilience foam
  • Wood furniture: Solid woods like cherry and pine

Concerns Regarding Durability for Both Brands

While both brands maintain certain quality standards, consumers have voiced concerns about durability. For Coleman Furniture, some users have reported wear and tear on their outdoor items within a year of use.

Ashley Furniture customers have noted issues related to the upholstery and fabric in their reviews, which may indicate a need for improved quality control.

Comparative Snapshot: Longevity and Quality

To better illustrate the differences and similarities in quality, the following table encapsulates key points:

BrandKnown ForConcerns
Coleman FurnitureWeather-resistant materials for outdoor use, hard-wearing woods for indoor useWear and tear on outdoor items
Ashley FurnitureHigh-resilience foam and solid woodsIssues with upholstery and fabric

Quality and material standards can be deciding factors in your furniture choice, and both Coleman and Ashley Furniture offer distinct advantages and limitations in this regard.

Pricing Strategy

While quality and variety are significant factors in choosing a furniture brand, pricing remains an undeniable concern for most consumers. Coleman Furniture and Ashley Furniture adopt distinct pricing strategies, each catering to different segments of the market. This section will examine these approaches in greater detail.

Coleman Furniture: Price Ranges for Different Product Categories

Coleman Furniture offers a variety of price points to cater to diverse consumer needs. Here are some approximate ranges for their major product categories:

  • Indoor Furniture: $200 – $2000
  • Outdoor Furniture: $150 – $1800

Note: Coleman’s pricing strategy aims to provide a middle ground between affordability and luxury.

Ashley Furniture: Entry-Level to High-End Products

Ashley Furniture’s product line is expansive, with options that range from entry-level to high-end.

  • Entry-Level: Starting at around $100 for basic chairs
  • Mid-Range: Sofas and dining sets often priced between $500 and $1500
  • High-End: Customizable sets can go upwards of $3000

Regular Promotions and Special Offers

Both Coleman and Ashley Furniture have a strong focus on promotions and special offers. Coleman frequently offers package deals, especially during holiday seasons, while Ashley provides financing options and frequent sales, particularly online.

Comparative Snapshot: Affordability and Value

To provide a more straightforward comparison, the following table highlights the key pricing aspects of each brand:

BrandEntry-LevelMid-RangeHigh-EndSpecial Offers
Coleman Furniture$200$600$2000Package Deals
Ashley Furniture$100$1000$3000+Financing Options, Sales

Taking everything into account, Coleman Furniture and Ashley Furniture offer different pricing strategies to cater to varied customer needs. Coleman often finds the middle ground for those seeking balance between cost and quality, whereas Ashley provides a broader range, from budget-friendly to premium options.

Customer Policies and Support

Customer service policies and support features play an essential role in the overall shopping experience. Both Coleman Furniture vs Ashley Furniture have crafted customer-focused policies to enhance satisfaction and retention. Let’s scrutinize these policies to better understand what each brand offers.

Coleman Furniture: Return and Shipping Policies

Coleman Furniture takes a straightforward approach to its customer policies. Here are key aspects of their return and shipping procedures:

  • Free shipping on most items
  • 30-day return policy
  • Restocking fee applicable

Note: Coleman Furniture’s free shipping is often a major selling point for online shoppers.

Ashley Furniture: Financing Options and Warranties

Ashley Furniture goes beyond basic policies to offer additional financial conveniences:

  1. Various financing options available
  2. Extended warranties on selected items
  3. Deferred payment plans

Customer Service: Responsiveness and Accessibility

Both brands make concerted efforts to provide accessible and responsive customer service. Coleman Furniture offers live chat support and a detailed FAQ section, while Ashley Furniture has multiple contact points, including phone, email, and social media channels.

Comparative Snapshot: Ease of Purchase and Post-Purchase Support

To help streamline the decision-making process, the following table highlights customer policies and support features of both brands:

BrandShippingReturnsFinancingCustomer Support Channels
Coleman FurnitureFree30 daysNoneLive chat, FAQ
Ashley FurnitureVariableStore-basedMultiplePhone, email, social media

In summary, Coleman Furniture offers a more straightforward approach with free shipping and a standardized return policy, but lacks financing options.

Ashley Furniture provides a wider range of financial conveniences and customer support channels, offering a more comprehensive shopping experience for those who need it.

Unique Selling Propositions

Distinctive features are critical in setting a brand apart in a crowded marketplace. Coleman Furniture vs Ashley Furniture offer unique selling propositions that cater to diverse consumer needs.

This section will examine those distinct aspects, providing a comprehensive understanding of what makes each brand truly unique.

Coleman Furniture: Emphasis on Online Shopping and Delivery Services

Coleman Furniture leans heavily into the convenience of online shopping. Key points include:

  • User-friendly website interface
  • Extensive online catalog
  • Expedited delivery options
  • Virtual consultations

Note: Coleman Furniture’s online-centric model is especially advantageous for those who prefer digital shopping.

Ashley Furniture: Made in the U.S. and Amish Craftsmanship

Ashley Furniture takes a different route, focusing on product quality and craftsmanship:

  1. Majority of products made in the U.S.
  2. Use of Amish craftsmanship in some collections
  3. Availability of custom options

Differentiators That Set Each Brand Apart

While Coleman Furniture appeals to the digital shopper with its online services, Ashley Furniture captures a market segment that values domestic production and quality craftsmanship.

These are not merely aesthetic choices; they reflect the core philosophy of each brand.

Comparative Snapshot: Uniqueness and Appeal

To facilitate easier comparison, here is a table highlighting the unique selling propositions of both brands:

Coleman FurnitureOnline ShoppingUser-friendly interface, expedited delivery
Ashley FurnitureCraftsmanshipMade in U.S., Amish craftsmanship, custom options

Each brand has carved out its own niche in the furniture market. Coleman Furniture tends to attract those who value the ease and speed of online shopping, while Ashley Furniture lures customers seeking quality and artisanal craftsmanship. Both approaches offer distinct advantages, depending on individual customer needs and preferences.

Pros and Cons

Every choice comes with its set of benefits and limitations. The furniture brands Coleman Furniture and Ashley Furniture are no exceptions to this rule.

This section aims to shed light on the key strengths and weaknesses of each brand to help consumers make an informed decision.

Coleman Furniture: Strengths and Weaknesses


  • Extensive online presence
  • Varied payment options
  • Rapid delivery services


  • Limited physical stores
  • May lack artisanal touch

Note: Coleman Furniture is optimal for those who prioritize a seamless online shopping experience.

Ashley Furniture: Strengths and Weaknesses


  1. Wide range of quality materials
  2. Domestic and artisanal production
  3. Diverse style options


  1. Generally higher pricing
  2. Limited online customization

Which Brand Caters to Specific Needs?

Coleman Furniture is tailored for the consumer who values convenience, speed, and an array of online options. On the other hand, Ashley Furniture targets the discerning buyer who is willing to invest in quality and craftsmanship, possibly at a higher price point.

Comparative Snapshot: Overall Advantages and Drawbacks

For a clear comparison, we present a table that summarizes the pros and cons of both brands.

Coleman FurnitureOnline presence, payment options, rapid deliveryLimited physical stores, less artisanal quality
Ashley FurnitureQuality materials, domestic production, diverse stylesHigher pricing, limited online customization

While each brand comes with its unique strengths and limitations, what ultimately matters is which brand aligns with your personal needs and preferences.

Both Coleman Furniture vs Ashley Furniture offer compelling options, each appealing to different consumer types.

Read Also: Jonathan Louis vs Ashley Furniture – A Brilliant Buying Guide


We’ve dissected multiple facets such as product offerings and customer policies, which highlight the distinguishing features of Coleman and Ashley Furniture. When it comes to convenience and a variety of online options, Coleman Furniture has a competitive edge.

On the other hand, Ashley Furniture takes the lead in craftsmanship and material quality. Coleman Furniture is well-suited for the modern, digital-savvy shopper, whereas Ashley Furniture caters to consumers who prioritize quality and a wide range of options.

Armed with this comprehensive knowledge, you are now poised to make an informed choice. Your ideal home setting awaits; make your selection wisely.