Home » Furniture » Smith Brothers vs Flexsteel – What You Must Know
Smith Brothers vs Flexsteel - What You Must Know

Smith Brothers vs Flexsteel – What You Must Know

by Ethan Ross

Selecting the ideal furniture is more than just a casual decision; it’s a significant investment. That’s why comparing brands like Smith Brothers vs Flexsteel is so vital.

Both companies have carved out unique positions in the industry, distinguished by their emphasis on quality and craftsmanship.

This article aims to dissect these two brands methodically, focusing on their history, product range, customization options, and customer feedback, among other criteria.

With so much to consider, making an informed decision is essential. Let’s get into the details that will help you do just that.

Quick Comparison

Feature/AspectSmith BrothersFlexsteel
Foundation Year19261893
OriginAmish, now Swiss AmishRolph & Ball Furniture Company
Main ProductsSofas, recliners, ottomansBedroom, dining, sofas, living room, kitchen
Customization OptionsAvailableLimited
Materials UsedHardwood maple, steel coil springs, etc.Not specified
Unique Selling PointQuality and craftsmanshipBlue Steel Spring, craftsmanship
Price RangeMid to high-endVaries
WarrantyLifetime on core componentsVaries; Lifetime Limited Warranty on some parts
Customer FeedbackMostly positiveNot specified
Business ModelB2B (through dealers)B2B (through retailers)
Customer ServiceMixed reviewsDepends on retailer
ConsExpensive, dealer-related issuesLimited direct purchase, depends on retailer
Manufacturing LocationBerne, IndianaNot specified

History and Evolution

Understanding the history and evolution of Smith Brothers vs Flexsteel offers valuable insights into their respective philosophies and business practices.

This section delves into the origins and growth patterns of both brands, changes in their business models, and the impact of these shifts on their product line and brand identity.

Origin of Smith Brothers and Its Evolution

Smith Brothers originated as a family-owned enterprise focusing on high-quality materials and superior craftsmanship. Over the years, the company has experienced considerable growth, expanding its product offerings and market reach. One notable change has been the introduction of sustainable materials, reflecting an industry-wide push for eco-friendly products.

Foundation and Growth of Flexsteel

Flexsteel was founded on the principle of durability, as reflected in their patented Blue Steel Spring technology. Since its inception, Flexsteel has evolved into a broad-spectrum furniture manufacturer, offering everything from residential to commercial solutions. Their commitment to innovation has kept them at the forefront of the furniture market.

Note: Flexsteel’s Blue Steel Spring technology has become a highly recognized standard for quality in the furniture industry.

Changes in Business Models Over Time

Both Smith Brothers and Flexsteel have had to adapt to changing market conditions. Smith Brothers made a strategic decision to go direct-to-consumer, capitalizing on the growing trend of online shopping. Flexsteel, on the other hand, diversified by venturing into the commercial furniture space.

  • Smith Brothers: Shifted to direct-to-consumer
  • Flexsteel: Expanded into commercial furniture

Impact on Product Line and Brand Identity

The evolutionary paths of these two companies have influenced their product lines and brand identities in meaningful ways. Smith Brothers has been steadfast in maintaining a reputation for high-quality, custom furniture. Flexsteel has similarly valued quality but has also added versatility to its brand ethos, as seen in its wide range of products.

This nuanced history allows consumers to understand what sets each brand apart, aiding in the decision-making process.

Read Also: Arhaus vs Room and Board – The Definitive Contrast

Product Range and Customization

Consumers often seek a blend of variety and personalization when choosing furniture. Smith Brothers and Flexsteel, despite their distinct histories, both offer a range of products, albeit with varying degrees of customization options.

This section will provide an extensive look at the types of furniture offered by each brand and the customization features they bring to the table.

Types of Furniture Offered by Smith Brothers

Smith Brothers takes pride in offering a wide array of furniture options, predominantly for residential settings.

Their product line includes:

  • Sofas and loveseats
  • Armchairs and recliners
  • Dining sets
  • Bedroom furniture

Note: Smith Brothers particularly excels in offering an extensive range of upholstery choices.

Types of Furniture Offered by Flexsteel

Flexsteel, on the other hand, extends its product range to both residential and commercial settings. Their offerings include:

  • Office furniture
  • Home seating solutions
  • Hospitality furniture
  • Vehicle seats

Customization Options Available with Smith Brothers

One of the notable features of Smith Brothers is the extent to which their furniture can be customized. From fabric selection to leg finishes, consumers can truly tailor their pieces to reflect personal style.

Customization FeaturesSmith Brothers
Fabric ChoicesExtensive
Frame OptionsMultiple
Leg FinishesVaried

Limited Customization Features of Flexsteel

While Flexsteel does offer some customization, the options are comparatively limited. Flexsteel primarily focuses on variations in material and size rather than extensive aesthetic customization.

Customization FeaturesFlexsteel
Material ChoicesLimited
Size OptionsAvailable
Design CustomizationNot Extensive

This discussion of product range and customization illustrates the diverging paths the two companies have taken to meet consumer needs, providing a valuable perspective for potential buyers.

Quality and Materials

Quality is a paramount concern for anyone investing in furniture. While Smith Brothers and Flexsteel both promise high-quality products, the materials they use and their unique features paint a different picture.

Let’s delve into the specifics of what sets each brand apart in terms of materials and overall quality.

Key Materials Used by Smith Brothers

Smith Brothers employs a stringent material selection process to maintain their high quality standards.

Their primary materials include:

  • Hardwood for frames
  • High-density foam for cushions
  • Premium fabric and leather for upholstery
HardwoodStructural integrity
High-density foamComfort and durability
Premium upholsteryAesthetic appeal

Uniqueness of Flexsteel’s Blue Steel Spring

Flexsteel distinguishes itself with its patented Blue Steel Spring technology. This unique feature ensures consistent comfort and durability over time.

Note: The Blue Steel Spring is backed by a lifetime warranty, providing extra assurance to customers.

Durability and Longevity

Durability is a key consideration for both brands. Smith Brothers uses interlocking frames and reinforced corners, while Flexsteel relies on its Blue Steel Spring to promise longevity. It’s not just about aesthetics; it’s about furniture that lasts.

Customer Reviews on Quality

User feedback plays a pivotal role in validating a brand’s claims. Both Smith Brothers or Flexsteel garner predominantly positive reviews.

However, it is notable that Smith Brothers often receives praise for the tactile quality of its materials, whereas Flexsteel tends to be lauded for its long-lasting comfort.

In dissecting the quality and materials used by Smith Brothers and Flexsteel, consumers have a better foundation for making an informed decision. Quality is more than skin deep; it’s about what lies beneath the surface.

Key Differences

Deciding between Smith Brothers and Flexsteel involves more than just individual preferences for style or comfort.

A series of crucial differences, such as business models, customization options, warranty terms, and pricing, offer additional layers of consideration. We shall now scrutinize these aspects in detail.

Business Models and How They Affect Customers

Smith Brothers operates on a more traditional model, emphasizing brick-and-mortar stores, allowing customers to see and feel products before purchase. Flexsteel, on the other hand, embraces a blend of online and in-store shopping experiences.

Business ModelCustomer Impact
Traditional (Smith)Enhanced sensory evaluation
Hybrid (Flexsteel)Convenience and broader reach

Customization and Its Impact on Consumer Choice

Smith Brothers goes above and beyond in offering a wide array of customization options, from fabrics to finishes. Flexsteel, though offering some level of customization, is more limited in scope.

Note: Greater customization can significantly influence consumer choice and satisfaction.

Warranty Terms and What They Signify

Warranty terms are often overlooked but are pivotal in the long-term value of your furniture investment. Smith Brothers typically offers more comprehensive warranty terms, while Flexsteel’s Blue Steel Spring comes with a lifetime warranty, but only for that specific component.

Price Point Analysis and What it Indicates

While Smith Brothers usually comes at a higher price point, the company justifies this through customization and material quality. Flexsteel is generally more budget-friendly but offers fewer customization options.

Price PointIndication
Higher (Smith)Premium customization, materials
Lower (Flexsteel)Limited customization, cost-saving

Understanding these key differences between Smith Brothers and Flexsteel provides a clearer picture for those deciding between the two brands. We’ve gone beyond surface-level features to consider the underlying factors that will affect your long-term satisfaction.

Which is Better?

The question of superiority between Smith Brothers vs Flexsteel ultimately depends on individual priorities.

Is material quality more significant to you, or do customization features hold more weight?

How much does warranty and customer service affect your decision?

We will dissect these parameters to offer a balanced viewpoint, facilitating your decision-making process.

Comparison Based on Material Quality

When it comes to material quality, Smith Brothers tends to have the upper hand with its focus on premium fabrics and finishes. Flexsteel isn’t far behind, but their standout feature is the patented Blue Steel Spring technology.

Material QualitySmith BrothersFlexsteel
Spring MechanismTraditionalBlue Steel Spring

Considerations for Customization Features

Customization features can be a game-changer. Smith Brothers offers an extensive range of options, allowing for a more personalized experience. Flexsteel, while offering some customization, is not as flexible in this regard.

Note: The level of customization can dramatically affect the overall satisfaction and utility of the furniture.

Warranty and Customer Service as Indicators

Both companies offer warranties, but Smith Brothers typically provides more comprehensive terms.

Customer service is comparable, although the specifics can vary depending on the retailer.

Warranty/Customer ServiceSmith BrothersFlexsteel
Customer ServiceVariesVaries

Final Recommendations

If quality materials and customization are high on your list, Smith Brothers may be the better option for you. For those prioritizing a blend of durability and cost-effectiveness, Flexsteel might be more fitting. We’ve equipped you with the tools to make an informed choice; the final decision rests with you.

Read Also: Craftmaster vs La-Z-Boy – A Side-by-Side Comparison


We’ve thoroughly evaluated Smith Brothers vs Flexsteel, from their historical roots to the intricacies of their product offerings.

Understanding the unique features and limitations of each brand can significantly influence your choice. For those seeking higher quality materials and extensive customization, Smith Brothers holds the edge.

Alternatively, Flexsteel provides a balanced blend of durability and cost-effectiveness. With these insights, you’re better equipped to make an informed decision that aligns with your specific needs.